FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
File number:  
QUD 233 of 2022  
DOWNES J  
Judgment of:  
Date of judgment:  
Catchwords:  
14 September 2022  
CORPORATIONS – application pursuant to s 588FM(1)  
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for an order fixing a later time  
for the purposes of s 588FL(2)(b)(iv) – failure to register  
security interest due to inadvertence – order made with  
imposition of Guardian Securities condition  
CORPORATIONS – application pursuant to s 293(1)  
Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) for an  
extension of the number of business days in the period  
specified in s 62(3) – failure to register security interest due  
to inadvertence – just and equitable to make orders sought –  
orders made  
Legislation:  
Cases cited:  
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 588FL, 588FM  
Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12(3), 13,  
14, 62, 63, 293  
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v HM Aircraft Holdings  
Pty Ltd (2021) 152 ACSR 63; [2021] FCA 447  
Elimatta Pty Ltd v NT Bullion Pty Ltd, in the matter of NT  
Bullion Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 1416  
One Corporate Trust Services Ltd v MLSP Assets Pty Ltd in  
its capacity as trustee for the MLSP Assets Trust [2022]  
FCA 555  
In the matter of Appleyard Capital Pty Limited; 123  
Sweden AB v Appleyard Capital Pty Limited (2014) 101  
ACSR 629; [2014] NSWSC 782  
Squadron Resources Pty Ltd v Highlake Resources Pty Ltd,  
in the matter of Highlake Resources Pty Ltd [2018] FCA  
1292  
Von Arx v Todae Solar Pty Ltd, in the matter of Todae  
Solar Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2020] FCA 1071  
Division:  
General Division  
Registry:  
Queensland  
National Practice Area:  
Commercial and Corporations  
Sub-area:  
Corporations and Corporate Insolvency  
39  
Number of paragraphs:  
Date of last submission/s:  
Date of hearing:  
9 September 2022  
23 August 2022  
Mr M Stunden  
Counsel for the Applicants:  
Solicitor for the Applicants:  
Thomson Geer  
Counsel for the First  
Respondent:  
No appearance  
Counsel for the Second  
Respondent:  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
Counsel for the Third  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Fourth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Fifth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Sixth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Seventh  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Eighth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Ninth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Tenth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Eleventh  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Twelfth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Thirteenth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Fourteenth  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Fifteenth  
Respondent:  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
Counsel for the Sixteenth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Seventeenth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Eighteenth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Nineteenth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Twentieth  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Twenty First No appearance  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Twenty  
Second Respondent:  
No appearance  
Counsel for the Twenty Third No appearance  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Twenty  
Fourth Respondent:  
No appearance  
Counsel for the Twenty Fifth No appearance  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Twenty Sixth No appearance  
Respondent:  
Counsel for the Twenty  
Seventh Respondent:  
No appearance  
No appearance  
No appearance  
Counsel for the Twenty  
Eighth Respondent:  
Counsel for the Twenty  
Ninth Respondent:  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
ORDERS  
QUD 233 of 2022  
BETWEEN:  
EVOLUTION FLEET SERVICES PTY LTD ACN 132 010 596  
First Applicant  
EVOLUTION ASSET MANAGEMENT ACN 109 296 746  
Second Applicant  
AND:  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161 000  
First Respondent  
ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514  
Second Respondent  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116 130 922 (and  
others named in the Schedule)  
Third Respondent  
ORDER MADE BY: DOWNES J  
DATE OF ORDER: 14 SEPTEMBER 2022  
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:  
1
.
.
The applicants have leave to amend the originating process in the form of annexure  
ALM-47 to the affidavit of Ms Alice Morrow affirmed on 12 September 2022.  
2
Pursuant to s 588FM of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), 21 June 2022 is fixed as the  
time for the applicants to register on the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR)  
each PPSR registration referred to in Schedule A and Schedule B annexed to these  
orders for the purposes of s 588FL(2)(b)(iv) of the Corporations Act.  
3.  
Pursuant to s 293(1)(a) of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth), the  
number of business days set out in s 62(3)(b) of that Act is extended, in respect of  
each registration referred to in Schedule A to these orders, so that the period will  
expire on 21 June 2022.  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
i
4.  
Any liquidator, administrator or deed administrator of any of the first to seventh, tenth  
to twelfth, fourteenth and sixteenth respondents has liberty to apply to discharge or  
vary order 2 if any winding up of any such respondent occurs, or an administrator is  
appointed to such respondent under ss 436A, 436B or 436C of the Corporations Act,  
or any such respondent executes a deed of company arrangement, within six months  
of 21 June 2022.  
5.  
The applicants have liberty to apply.  
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
ii  
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  
DOWNES J:  
INTRODUCTION  
1
2
This is an application pursuant to s 588FM(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for an  
order fixing a later time for the purposes of s 588FL(2)(b)(iv) of the Corporations Act in  
respect of registrations made by the applicants against certain collateral.  
An order is also sought pursuant to s 293(1) of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009  
(Cth) (PPSA) for an extension of the number of business days in the period specified in s  
62(3) of the PPSA. This is sought to protect what is known as super priority, which is  
conferred by ss 62 and 63 PPSA.  
3
4
There are some circumstances of urgency in relation to this matter as the orders are required  
to be made by 20 September 2022.  
Part of the applicants’ principal business activity is to manage a commercial vehicle hire  
business under the business name “Surefleet”. The orders are sought in circumstances where  
the applicants were late in registering certain security interests over a number of fleet vehicles  
on the Personal Properties Security Register (PPSR).  
5
Since the originating process was filed and the matter was heard on 23 August 2022, the  
applicants sought leave to amend the originating process in the form of annexure ALM-47 to  
the affidavit of Ms Alice Morrow affirmed on 12 September 2022. That leave will be granted  
because the effect of the amendments is to reduce the scope of the orders sought as well as  
the number of respondents, and there is no prejudice to any person caused by the  
amendments.  
6
The grantors of security interests in the vehicles, which are the subject of the modified  
application (Grantor Respondents), and their AllPAP security holders (AllPAP  
Respondents), were joined to the proceedings, were served, did not appear at the hearing on  
23 August 2022 and expressly did not oppose the relief sought.  
7
For the reasons below, the orders sought by the applicants will be made in accordance with  
the terms of the proposed further amended originating process with a modification to  
paragraph 3, as discussed below. Further, the orders sought in paragraph 4 of the proposed  
further amended originating process were made on 23 August 2022.  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
1
RELEVANT BACKGROUND TO APPLICATIONS  
8
Evolution Group Holdings Pty Ltd (Evolution) is the holding company of both applicants,  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd (EFS) and Evolution Asset Management Pty Ltd (EAM).  
These three companies form part of the Evolution Group.  
9
1
On 27 January 2017, Evolution and EFS entered into a business sale agreement to purchase  
the business known as “Surefleet Australia” from Cashcownow Pty Ltd.  
0
1
The internal structure of the Evolution Group is such that EAM owns vehicles and leases  
them to EFS, which in turn leases them to third party customers as part of the “Surefleet”  
business.  
1
Each of the leases to the third parties in this case are for a term of more than two years or are  
a lease for an indefinite term in a case in which the lessee, with the consent of EFS, has  
retained uninterrupted (or substantially uninterrupted) possession of the vehicle for a period  
of more than two years after the day on which the lessee first acquired possession of it. For  
that reason, each of the leases of the vehicles listed in the Updated Master Schedule annexed  
to the affidavit of Mr Andrew Baxter sworn on 9 September 2022, and the annexures to the  
further amended originating process, is a PPS lease within the meaning of s 13 of the PPSA.  
It follows that EFS has a security interest as well as a purchase money security interest or  
PMSI within the meaning of that Act: ss 12(3) and 14 PPSA.  
12  
The acquisition of the Surefleet business by EFS was initially by vendor finance which was  
replaced with an asset finance facility from NAB. Evolution also has a loan facility with  
NAB. Both facilities are secured in large part by vehicles owned by EAM. The board of  
Evolution has sought, and is well advanced in negotiations with, refinancing with another  
financier, with a view to that financier acquiring the debt of NAB and entering into new  
facility agreements with the Evolution Group.  
13  
It was during the due diligence process into this refinance during May 2022 that it was  
discovered that EFS had failed to register its security interests in the relevant vehicles, either  
effectively or at all. In particular, it was discovered in May 2022 that attempts in April 2022  
by the then employed fleet administrator of Evolution to register a security interest in certain  
vehicles had been done incorrectly.  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
2
14  
The orders sought by the applicants are required to be made before the new financier will  
agree to refinance the facilities. Mr Stunden of counsel, who appeared for the applicants,  
submitted that that order needed to be made by 20 September 2022.  
APPLICATION PURSUANT TO SECTION 588FM CORPORATIONS ACT  
Relevant legislation  
15  
Section 588FL(2)(b)(ii) of the Corporations Act requires a security interest to be registered  
within 20 business days of the security agreement that gave rise to the security interest  
coming into force. A later time may be fixed as provided for by s 588FL(2)(b)(iv) if an  
application is made under s 588FM(1).  
16  
Section 588FL of the Corporations Act relevantly provides:  
(
2)  
This subsection covers a PPSA security interest if:  
(
a)  
at the critical time, or, if the security interest arises after the critical  
time, when the security interest arises:  
(
i)  
the security interest is enforceable against third parties under  
the law of Australia; and  
(
ii)  
the security interest is perfected by registration, and by no  
other means; and  
(
b)  
the registration time for the collateral is after the latest of the  
following times:  
(
(
i)  
6 months before the critical time;  
ii)  
the time that is the end of 20 business days after the security  
agreement that gave rise to the security interest came into  
force, or the time that is the critical time, whichever time is  
earlier;  
(
iii)  
if the security agreement giving rise to the security interest  
came into force under the law of a foreign jurisdiction, but  
the security interest first became enforceable against third  
parties under the law of Australia after the time that is 6  
months before the critical time—the time that is the end of  
56 days after the security interest became so enforceable, or  
the time that is the critical time, whichever time is earlier;  
(
iv)  
a later time ordered by the Court under section 588FM.  
(
4)  
The PPSA security interest vests in the company at the following time, unless  
the security interest is unaffected by this section because of section 588FN:  
(
a)  
if the security interest first becomes enforceable against third parties  
at or before the critical time—immediately before the event  
mentioned in paragraph (1)(a);  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
3
(
b)  
if the security interest first becomes enforceable against third parties  
after the critical time—at the time it first becomes so enforceable.  
(
7)  
In this section:  
critical time, in relation to a company, means:  
(
(
(
a)  
b)  
c)  
if the company is being wound up—when, on a day, the event occurs  
by virtue of which the winding up is taken to have begun or  
commenced on that day under section 513A or 513B; or  
if the company is under administration or is subject to a deed of  
company arrangement—when, on a day, the event occurs by virtue  
of which the day is the section 513C day for the company; or  
if the company is under restructuring or is subject to a restructuring  
plan—when, on a day, the event occurs by virtue of which the day is  
the section 513CA day for the company.  
17  
Section 588FM of the Corporations Act relevantly provides:  
Extension of time for registration  
(
1)  
A company, or any person interested, may apply to the Court (within the  
meaning of section 58AA) for an order fixing a later time for the purposes of  
subparagraph 588FL(2)(b)(iv).  
(
2)  
On an application under this section, the Court may make the order sought if  
it is satisfied that:  
(
a)  
the failure to register the collateral earlier:  
(
i)  
was accidental or due to inadvertence or some other  
sufficient cause; or  
(
ii)  
is not of such a nature as to prejudice the position of  
creditors or shareholders; or  
(
b)  
on other grounds, it is just and equitable to grant relief.  
(
3)  
The Court may make the order sought on any terms and conditions that seem  
just and expedient to the Court.  
Consideration  
18  
Section 588FM(2) confers a broad judicial discretion informed, at least at one level, by what  
is “just and equitable”; as such, it is to be read liberally for the purpose intended by the  
statute in question and is not to be constrained or limited by glosses or implications not found  
in the relevant statute: see Squadron Resources Pty Ltd v Highlake Resources Pty Ltd, in the  
matter of Highlake Resources Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1292 at [35(b)] (McKerracher J); see also  
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v HM Aircraft Holdings Pty Ltd (2021) 152 ACSR 63;  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
4
[
2021] FCA 447 at [60] (Beach J); One Corporate Trust Services Ltd v MLSP Assets Pty Ltd  
in its capacity as trustee for the MLSP Assets Trust [2022] FCA 555 at [26] (Beach J).  
1
2
2
9
0
1
In this case, the applicants rely upon s 588FM(2)(a)(i) which requires them to establish that  
the failure to register the collateral earlier was accidental or due to inadvertence or some  
other sufficient cause.  
As observed by Beach J in HM Aircraft Holdings at [64], inadvertence within the meaning of  
the legislation can include a failure to turn one’s mind to the requirement to register so long  
as such a failure is not intended to flout, or is recklessly indifferent to, proper compliance.  
In Von Arx v Todae Solar Pty Ltd, in the matter of Todae Solar Pty Ltd (Administrators  
Appointed) [2020] FCA 1071 at [7], Jagot J accepted the proposition that inadvertence  
includes innocent error in the sense of failure to register through ignorance of the legal  
requirement to do so or of the consequences of not doing so. See also Elimatta Pty Ltd v NT  
Bullion Pty Ltd, in the matter of NT Bullion Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 1416 at [5] (Yates J).  
2
2
2
3
Having regard to the evidence adduced by the applicants in this case, I am satisfied that the  
failure to lodge the security interests for registration was the product of inadvertence within  
the meaning of s 588FM(2)(a)(i) Corporations Act.  
The relevant officers and employees have deposed to being ignorant of the requirement to  
register the security interests and there is no suggestion on the face of the evidence or by any  
person opposing the orders sought that the failure to lodge the security interests for  
registration was in any way deliberate or recklessly indifferent to proper compliance.  
24  
Once inadvertence has been established for the purposes of s 588FM(2), it remains necessary  
for the Court to exercise its discretion as to whether to make the orders sought, and whether  
such an order should be made on terms and conditions under s 588FM(3) of the Corporations  
Act: Squadron Resources at [35(e)].  
25  
The following considerations support the exercise of the discretion in favour of the order  
sought:  
(1)  
the exercise of the discretion is informed by the matters that enliven the discretion,  
namely, in this case, that the failure to lodge was the product of inadvertence due to  
ignorance of the legal requirements for registration;  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
5
(2)  
upon discovery of the need to register, the applicants acted promptly. Following the  
discovery of the need to register the security interests in May 2022, solicitors were  
consulted in June 2022 and this proceeding was commenced on 1 July 2022;  
(
3)  
4)  
the affected Grantor Respondents and the AllPAP Respondents did not oppose the  
making of the order sought;  
(
there is no evidence of the financial position of the Grantor Respondents but the  
interests of unsecured creditors will be adequately protected by the imposition of the  
condition proposed by the applicants in paragraph 3 of its proposed further amended  
originating process, with modifications including to remove the reference to the order  
sought pursuant to s 293(1)(a) of the PPSA (being something which was done in the  
draft order provided by the applicants). That is, the applicants seek to include what  
has been described in the authorities as a Guardian Securities condition as follows:  
Any liquidator, administrator or deed administrator of any of the first to  
seventh, tenth to twelfth, fourteenth and sixteenth respondents has liberty to  
apply to discharge or vary [the order made under s 588FM Corporations Act]  
if any winding up of any such respondent occurs, or an administrator is  
appointed to such respondent under ss 436A, 436B or 436C of the  
Corporations Act, or any such respondent executes a deed of company  
arrangement, within six months of 21 June 2022.  
26  
As to the imposition of such a condition, it was explained by Brereton J in In the matter of  
Appleyard Capital Pty Limited; 123 Sweden AB v Appleyard Capital Pty Limited (2014) 101  
ACSR 629; [2014] NSWSC 782 at [25]:  
The Australian authorities establish that the interests of the unsecured creditors are a  
relevant consideration, so that the court must have regard to the financial position of  
the company as at the time of the application for extension. If the company is shown  
to be financially secure, then it is unlikely that a “critical day” will arise in the  
foreseeable future and the grant of relief will not likely affect any person adversely  
(
Hewlett Packard at [29]); indeed, if solvency is established that is likely to be the  
end of the matter (Investa Properties Pty Ltd v Westpac Property Funds Management  
Ltd (2001) 187 ALR 462; 40 ACSR 124; [2001] NSWSC 1089 at [31]). But  
otherwise, where the court is not satisfied that there is no risk that unsecured  
creditors could be adversely affected, the unsecured creditors (or their representative)  
are entitled to be heard against the making of an order, though this may sufficiently  
be achieved by suspending the operation of the order, or by imposing a term  
reserving leave to apply to set it aside in the event of a liquidation or administration  
(
a Guardian Securities condition): [Re Guardian Securities Ltd [1984] 1 NSWLR 95]  
at 97; see also Re Cinema Art Films [1930] NZLR 500 at 502–3 (Cinema Art Films);  
Re L H Charles & Co Ltd (1935) WN(Eng) 15 (L H Charles & Co); Bevillesta, 58.  
27  
In all of the circumstances, I am satisfied that the order sought by the applicants should be  
made with the date to be fixed as 21 June 2022, being the last date referred to in the  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
6
Annexures to the further amended originating process. It is just and expedient to impose the  
condition referred to above.  
APPLICATION PURSUANT TO SECTION 293 PPSA  
2
2
3
8
9
0
The applicants also seek an order under s 293(1)(a) of the PPSA extending the number of  
business days to have lodged a financing statement on the PPSR in respect of the Schedule A  
Registrations to the proposed further amended originating process.  
This relief is sought because the failure to lodge a registration on the PPSR in respect of a  
PMSI within 15 business days from the grantor obtaining possession of the relevant goods  
disentitles the secured party to the super priority afforded to the PMSI under the PPSA.  
Section 293 of the PPSA relevantly provides:  
293  
Timing—applications for extension of time  
(
1)  
On application, a court may make an order extending the number of business  
days in a period specified in the following provisions if the court is satisfied  
that it is just and equitable to do so:  
(
interests);  
a)  
paragraphs 62(3)(b) (perfection of purchase money security  
(
(
2)  
3)  
The court may make the order even if the period has ended.  
In making an order to extend a period under subsection (1), the court must  
take into account the following:  
(
(
(
a)  
b)  
c)  
whether the need to extend the period arises as a result of an  
accident, inadvertence or some other sufficient cause;  
whether extending the period would prejudice the position of any  
other secured parties or other creditors;  
whether any person has acted, or not acted, in reliance on the period  
having ended.  
3
3
1
2
Each of the relevant elements to be satisfied will now be addressed.  
Perfection of purchase money security interests  
In this case, the applicants seek the perfection of PMSIs which arise by reason of the interest  
held in the PPS leases. Section 293(1)(a) PPSA is therefore satisfied.  
Whether need to extend period arises as a result of accident or inadvertence  
33  
Inadvertence or accident for the purposes of s 293(3)(a) of the PPSA has the same meaning as  
their cognate forms in s 588FM of the Corporations Act: see HM Aircraft Holdings at [82].  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
7
34  
For the same reasons as I found that there was inadvertence within the meaning of s 588FM  
of the Corporations Act, I am satisfied that the need to extend the period pursuant to s 293 of  
the PPSA arises as a result of inadvertence.  
Whether extending the period would prejudice the position of any other secured parties  
or other creditors  
35  
In this case, I am satisfied that extending the period will not prejudice the position of any  
other secured parties or other creditors, or that any such prejudice is not such as to justify  
refusing to make the order sought, because of the absence of opposition to the order sought  
including by the AllPAP Respondents.  
Whether any person has acted, or not acted, in reliance on the period having ended  
3
3
3
6
7
8
In this case and in the absence of any opposition by any AllPAP Respondent, I infer that no  
person has acted, or not acted, in reliance on the period having ended as referred to in  
s 293(3)(c) PPSA or the fact of any such reliance does not justify refusing to make the order  
sought.  
Whether just and equitable to make order sought  
I am therefore satisfied that it is just and equitable to make an order extending the number of  
business days in the period specified in s 62(3)(b) for the perfection by registration of each  
registration referred to in Schedule A to the further amended originating process so that the  
period will expire on 21 June 2022.  
CONCLUSION  
For these reasons, the following orders will be made:  
(
1)  
2)  
The applicants have leave to amend the originating process in the form of annexure  
ALM-47 to the affidavit of Ms Alice Morrow affirmed on 12 September 2022;  
(
Pursuant to s 588FM of the Corporations Act, 21 June 2022 is fixed as the time for  
the applicants to register on the PPSR each PPSR registration referred to in Schedule  
A and Schedule B annexed to these reasons for the purposes of s 588FL(2)(b)(iv) of  
the Corporations Act;  
(3)  
Pursuant to s 293(1)(a) of the PPSA, the number of business days set out in s 62(3)(b)  
of that Act is extended, in respect of each registration referred to in Schedule A to  
these reasons, so that the period will expire on 21 June 2022;  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
8
(4)  
Any liquidator, administrator or deed administrator of any of the first to seventh, tenth  
to twelfth, fourteenth and sixteenth respondents has liberty to apply to discharge or  
vary order 2 if any winding up of any such respondent occurs, or an administrator is  
appointed to such respondent under ss 436A, 436B or 436C of the Corporations Act,  
or any such respondent executes a deed of company arrangement, within six months  
of 21 June 2022.  
39  
In circumstances where material changes were made by the applicants to the originating  
process but without a further hearing having taken place, and because of the relative urgency  
associated with the application, I will also grant the applicants liberty to apply.  
I certify that the preceding thirty-  
nine (39) numbered paragraphs are a  
true copy of the Reasons for  
Judgment of the Honourable Justice  
Downes.  
Associate:  
Dated:  
14 September 2022  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
9
SCHEDULE OF PARTIES  
QUD 233 of 2022  
Respondents  
Fourth Respondent:  
J.A. MARTIN ELECTRICAL PTY LIMITED ACN 146  
08 063  
3
Fifth Respondent:  
Sixth Respondent:  
Seventh Respondent:  
GCO SOLAR PTY LTD ACN 123 571 059  
VENTIA AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ACN 093 114 553  
AUSTRALIAN RAIL TRACK CORPORATION  
LIMITED ACN 081 455 754  
Eighth Respondent:  
Ninth Respondent:  
DELTA GROUP PTY LTD ACN 165 323 222  
TRANSPORT FOR NSW ABN 18 804 239 602  
MASTERMYNE PTY LTD ACN 069 346 247  
AURIGA MARINE PTY LTD ACN 637 595 254  
BSR EPC PTY LTD ACN 621 591 580  
Tenth Respondent:  
Eleventh Respondent:  
Twelfth Respondent:  
Thirteenth Respondent:  
Fourteenth Respondent:  
Fifteenth Respondent:  
DOWNER EDI LIMITED ACN 003 872 848  
ENI AUSTRALIA LIMITED ACN 009 475 389  
GD. CONTRACTING & CIVIL PTY LTD ACN 619 485  
246  
Sixteenth Respondent:  
ROBOTICS OPTICS ELECTRONICS PTY LTD ACN  
41 246 513  
1
Seventeenth Respondent:  
Eighteenth Respondent:  
VERTECH GROUP PTY LTD ACN 132 745 665  
AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND BANKING  
GROUP LIMITED ACN 005 357 522  
Nineteenth Respondent:  
Twentieth Respondent:  
Twenty First Respondent:  
Twenty Second Respondent:  
BRISBANE AIRPORT CORPORATION PTY LIMITED  
ACN 076 870 650  
COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA ACN 123  
123 124  
JOB CONNECT RECRUITMENT PTY LTD ACN 145  
40 964  
0
JUDO BANK PTY LTD ACN 615 995 581  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
10  
Twenty Third Respondent:  
MINI-TANKERS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ACN 050 220  
16  
0
Twenty Fourth Respondent:  
Twenty Fifth Respondent:  
Twenty Sixth Respondent:  
Twenty Seventh Respondent:  
MAXI-TANKERS PTY LTD ACN 117 406 934  
IFUEL PTY LTD ACN 145 416 066  
NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED  
OAK CONSTRUCTION SERVICES PTY LTD ACN 622  
458 511  
Twenty Eighth Respondent:  
Twenty Ninth Respondent:  
SCOTTISH PACIFIC BUSINESS FINANCE PTY.  
LIMITED ACN 008 636 388  
WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION ACN 007 457  
141  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
11  
SCHEDULE A  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:18:31  
10/06/2022  
14:18:31  
202206100042683  
202206100043266  
202206100043664  
202206100043968  
202206100044374  
202206100044678  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MMAZLKL10KH006012  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:23:11  
10/06/2022  
14:23:11  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0FB3CD400290233  
MR0KA3CD301224204  
MR0KA3CD201224209  
MR0FB3CD500290080  
MR0FB3CD000270688  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:26:21  
10/06/2022  
14:26:21  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:28:59  
10/06/2022  
14:28:59  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:31:45  
10/06/2022  
14:31:45  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:33:58  
10/06/2022  
14:33:58  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:36:11  
10/06/2022  
14:36:11  
2
02206100044894  
02206100047399  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0KA3CD801188218  
MR0KA3CD601222432  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
All present and  
after acquired  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
10/06/2022  
14:55:44  
10/06/2022  
14:55:44  
2
Vehicle  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
12  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
property.  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
ACN 132 010 596  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:32:12  
10/06/2022  
15:32:12  
202206100051674  
202206100052408  
202206100054575  
202206100055012  
202206100055342  
202206100055684  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MMAZLKL10KH005887  
MMAZLKL10KH008404  
JTELV73J707806383  
JTELV73J007806340  
JTELV73J107806380  
JTELV73J107806363  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:36:44  
10/06/2022  
15:36:44  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:52:23  
10/06/2022  
15:52:23  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:57:03  
10/06/2022  
15:57:03  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:59:17  
10/06/2022  
15:59:17  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:01:22  
10/06/2022  
16:01:22  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:03:33  
10/06/2022  
16:03:33  
2
02206100055894  
02206100056195  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0FB3CD800270177  
MR0FB3CD500270668  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
All present and  
after acquired  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
10/06/2022  
16:05:41  
10/06/2022  
16:05:41  
2
Vehicle  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
13  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
property.  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
ACN 132 010 596  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:09:40  
10/06/2022  
16:09:40  
202206100056764  
202206100057141  
202206100060838  
202206100064100  
202206100064504  
202206100065617  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0FB3CDX00270732  
JTEBR3FJ30K027449  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:11:53  
10/06/2022  
16:11:53  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:22:03  
10/06/2022  
16:22:03  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0KA3CD501228349  
MR0KA3CDX01184493  
MMAZLKL10KH014785  
MMAYLKK10KH000230  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:28:35  
10/06/2022  
16:28:35  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:30:33  
10/06/2022  
16:30:33  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:40:36  
10/06/2022  
16:40:36  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:42:45  
10/06/2022  
16:42:45  
2
02206100065883  
02206100066830  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MMAZLKL10KH005526  
MMAYLKK10KH011366  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
All present and  
after acquired  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
10/06/2022  
16:48:21  
10/06/2022  
16:48:21  
2
Vehicle  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
14  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
property.  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
ACN 132 010 596  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:51:19  
10/06/2022  
16:51:19  
202206100067149  
202206100067407  
202206100067760  
202206100067929  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MMAZLKL10KH006025  
MMAZLKL10KH014777  
MMAZLKL10KH014782  
JTEBR3FJ50K129173  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:53:26  
10/06/2022  
16:53:26  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:56:59  
10/06/2022  
16:56:59  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:58:38  
10/06/2022  
16:58:38  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
Any and all  
motor  
vehicles  
which  
are  
hired, rented,  
leased, bailed,  
consigned,  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Plants Pty  
Ltd  
Motor  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD  
13/06/2022  
15:02:36  
13/06/2022  
15:02:36  
202206130024570  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
supplied  
otherwise  
made  
or  
property.  
available by  
the secured  
party to the  
grantor from  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
15  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
time to time  
including any  
modifications,  
parts,  
accessories,  
equipment,  
ancillary  
goods  
other  
or  
accessions to  
any  
such  
motor  
vehicles  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:18:31  
10/06/2022  
14:18:31  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
202206100042683  
202206100043266  
202206100043664  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MMAZLKL10KH006012  
MR0FB3CD400290233  
MR0KA3CD301224204  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:23:11  
10/06/2022  
14:23:11  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:26:21  
10/06/2022  
14:26:21  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:28:59  
10/06/2022  
14:28:59  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
202206100043968  
202206100044374  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0KA3CD201224209  
MR0FB3CD500290080  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
All present and  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:31:45  
10/06/2022  
14:31:45  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
16  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:33:58  
10/06/2022  
14:33:58  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
202206100044678  
202206100044894  
202206100047399  
202206100051674  
202206100052408  
202206100054575  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0FB3CD000270688  
MR0KA3CD801188218  
MR0KA3CD601222432  
MMAZLKL10KH005887  
MMAZLKL10KH008404  
JTELV73J707806383  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:36:11  
10/06/2022  
14:36:11  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:55:44  
10/06/2022  
14:55:44  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:32:12  
10/06/2022  
15:32:12  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:36:44  
10/06/2022  
15:36:44  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:52:23  
10/06/2022  
15:52:23  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:57:03  
10/06/2022  
15:57:03  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
202206100055012  
202206100055342  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
JTELV73J007806340  
JTELV73J107806380  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
All present and  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:59:17  
10/06/2022  
15:59:17  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
17  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:01:22  
10/06/2022  
16:01:22  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
202206100055684  
202206100055894  
202206100056195  
202206100056764  
202206100057141  
202206100060838  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
JTELV73J107806363  
MR0FB3CD800270177  
MR0FB3CD500270668  
MR0FB3CDX00270732  
JTEBR3FJ30K027449  
MR0KA3CD501228349  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:03:33  
10/06/2022  
16:03:33  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:05:41  
10/06/2022  
16:05:41  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:09:40  
10/06/2022  
16:09:40  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:11:53  
10/06/2022  
16:11:53  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:22:03  
10/06/2022  
16:22:03  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:28:35  
10/06/2022  
16:28:35  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
202206100064100  
202206100064504  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0KA3CDX01184493  
MMAZLKL10KH014785  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
All present and  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:30:33  
10/06/2022  
16:30:33  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
18  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:40:36  
10/06/2022  
16:40:36  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
202206100065617  
202206100065883  
202206100066830  
202206100067149  
202206100067407  
202206100067760  
202206100067929  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MMAYLKK10KH000230  
MMAZLKL10KH005526  
MMAYLKK10KH011366  
MMAZLKL10KH006025  
MMAZLKL10KH014777  
MMAZLKL10KH014782  
JTEBR3FJ50K129173  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:42:45  
10/06/2022  
16:42:45  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:48:21  
10/06/2022  
16:48:21  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:51:19  
10/06/2022  
16:51:19  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:53:26  
10/06/2022  
16:53:26  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:56:59  
10/06/2022  
16:56:59  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
16:58:38  
10/06/2022  
16:58:38  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS PTY LTD  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
19  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
Any and all  
motor  
vehicles  
which  
are  
hired, rented,  
leased, bailed,  
consigned,  
supplied  
otherwise  
made  
or  
available by  
the secured  
party to the  
grantor from  
time to time  
including any  
modifications,  
parts,  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Motor  
ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS PTY LTD  
13/06/2022  
15:25:33  
13/06/2022  
15:25:33  
Allroads Pty Ltd  
202206130025590  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
accessories,  
equipment,  
ancillary  
goods  
other  
or  
accessions to  
any  
such  
motor  
vehicles  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Solutions  
Pty Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:18:31  
10/06/2022  
14:18:31  
2
02206100042683  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MMAZLKL10KH006012  
MR0FB3CD400290233  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
Allroads Solutions  
202206100043266  
Motor  
All present and  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
10/06/2022  
10/06/2022  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
20  
PMSI Registrations (that were included in Schedule A to Originating Process)  
Registration  
Change  
Time  
Collateral  
Class  
Collateral  
Registration  
Start Time  
Nickname  
Number  
PMSI  
Proceeds  
Grantor  
Secured Party Group  
Serial Number  
Description  
Pty Ltd  
Vehicle  
after  
acquired  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
14:23:11  
14:23:11  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Solutions  
Pty Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:26:21  
10/06/2022  
14:26:21  
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
02206100043664  
02206100043968  
02206100044374  
02206100044678  
02206100044894  
02206100047399  
02206100051674  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MR0KA3CD301224204  
MR0KA3CD201224209  
MR0FB3CD500290080  
MR0FB3CD000270688  
MR0KA3CD801188218  
MR0KA3CD601222432  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Solutions  
Pty Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:28:59  
10/06/2022  
14:28:59  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Solutions  
Pty Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:31:45  
10/06/2022  
14:31:45  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Solutions  
Pty Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:33:58  
10/06/2022  
14:33:58  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Solutions  
Pty Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:36:11  
10/06/2022  
14:36:11  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Solutions  
Pty Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
14:55:44  
10/06/2022  
14:55:44  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
000; ALLROADS PTY LTD ACN 142 378 514;  
ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 116  
All present and  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
Allroads Solutions  
Pty Ltd  
Motor  
10/06/2022  
15:32:12  
10/06/2022  
15:32:12  
Yes  
Yes  
after  
acquired  
SERVICES PTY LTD  
ACN 132 010 596  
MMAZLKL10KH005887  
MMAZLKL10KH008404  
Vehicle  
property.  
130 922; ALLROADS SOLUTIONS PTY LTD  
Allroads Solutions  
202206100052408  
Motor  
All present and  
ALLROADS PLANT PTY LTD ACN 142 161  
EVOLUTION  
FLEET  
10/06/2022  
10/06/2022  
Evolution Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Allroads Plant Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1084  
21