October 3, 2000
ATEL Capital Equipment Fund IX, LLC
235 Pine Street, 6th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94104
Re: Federal Income Tax Consequences
Ladies and Gentlemen:
You have requested our opinion with respect to certain Federal income
tax matters in connection with the transactions contemplated by the prospectus
forming part of the Registration Statement filed with the Securities and
Exchange Commission on or about the date hereof (the Prospectus"), relating to
the offering of securities of ATEL Capital Equipment Fund IX, LLC (the "Fund").
All terms used herein have the respective meanings set forth in the Prospectus.
We have acted as special tax counsel to the Fund with respect to the
offering of Units. This letter is for delivery in connection with the offering
made by the Prospectus and is intended to confirm as of the effective date of
the Registration Statement certain opinions described in the "Federal Income Tax
Consequences" section of the Prospectus. This letter and the opinions confirmed
herein are for delivery to the Fund. We hereby consent to the use of this
opinion as an exhibit to the Registration Statement of the Fund and to the
reference to this firm in the Prospectus under the caption "Experts."
In rendering the opinion stated below and confirming the opinions
referred to in the Prospectus, we have examined and relied upon the following:
(i) The Limited Liability Company Operating Agreement dated September
27, 2000 (the "Operating Agreement) of the Fund;
(ii) The Prospectus and the Registration Statement; and
(iii) Such other documents, records and instruments as we have deemed
necessary in order to enable us to render the opinions referred to in this
letter.
<PAGE>
ATEL Capital Equipment Fund IX, LLC
October 3, 2000
Page 2
For purposes of rendering the opinion stated below and confirming the
other opinions referred to in the Prospectus, we have assumed:
(a) The truth and accuracy of the statements contained in the
Prospectus;
(b) That the Operating Agreement has not been amended, restated, or
otherwise revised;
(c) That the Fund has been duly formed and is validly existing under
the laws of the State of California and has been organized and has been and will
be operated at all times during its existence in accordance with the provisions
of its Operating Agreement, the description of its organization and operation
contained in the Prospectus, and all applicable state statutes pertaining to
limited partnerships;
(d) In those cases in which we have not been involved directly in the
preparation, execution or the filing of a document, that (i) the document
reviewed by us is an original document, or a true and accurate copy of the
original document, and has not been subsequently amended, (ii) the signatures on
each original document are genuine, and (iii) each party who executed the
document had proper authority and capacity;
(e) The factual representations, views and beliefs of the Manager
referred to in the "Federal Income Tax Consequences" section of the Prospectus,
including, but not limited to, the representation that the Fund will not elect
to be treated as a corporation for Federal tax purposes under the Regulations,
are true, correct and accurate;
(f) That neither the Fund nor its Members will elect to be excluded
from the partnership provisions of the Code; and
(g) That the Units are not and will not be (i) listed on an established
securities market, nor (ii) readily tradable on a secondary market or the
substantial equivalent thereof.
Our opinion set forth in this letter and the opinions referred to in
the Prospectus and confirmed below are based upon the California Revised Limited
Partnership Act (Cal. Corp. Code ss.15611, et seq.), the Internal Revenue Code
of 1986, as amended, existing and proposed regulations of the Treasury
Department, reports and statements of Congressional committees and members,
published administrative announcements and rulings of the Internal Revenue
Service, and court decisions, all as of the date of this letter.
For the reasons stated in the "Federal Income Tax Consequences" section
of the Prospectus as discussed therein, we are of the view that it is not
<PAGE>
ATEL Capital Equipment Fund IX, LLC
October 3, 2000
Page 3
possible for us to reach a judgment as to the probable outcome (either favorable
or unfavorable) of certain Federal income tax issues and accordingly we give no
opinion with respect to said issues.
Based on the foregoing, we hereby confirm that each of the statements
in the Prospectus in which it is stated that tax counsel has advised the Fund of
an opinion as to the probable outcome of an issue if the issue were fully
litigated in court is our current opinion as to such issue subject to all of the
qualifications, limitations and assumptions relating to such opinion.
The opinions set forth or confirmed above represent our conclusions as
to the application of Federal income tax law existing as of the date of this
letter to the transactions contemplated in the Prospectus, and we can give no
assurance that legislative enactments, administrative changes or court decisions
may not be forthcoming which would modify or supersede our opinions. Moreover,
there can be no assurance that positions contrary to our opinions will not be
taken by the Internal Revenue Service or that a court considering the issues
will not hold contrary to such opinions. Further, all of the opinions set forth
above represent our conclusions based upon the documents and facts referred to
above. Any material amendments to such documents or changes in any significant
facts could affect the opinions referred to herein. Although we have made such
inquiries and performed such investigation as we have deemed necessary to
fulfill our professional responsibilities as tax counsel, we have not undertaken
an independent investigation of the facts referred to in this letter.
We express no opinion as to any Federal income tax issue or other
matter except those set forth or confirmed above.
Very truly yours,
DERENTHAL & DANNHAUSER
