BIG B INC
SC 14D9/A, 1996-10-02
DRUG STORES AND PROPRIETARY STORES
Previous: IDS DISCOVERY FUND INC, N-30D, 1996-10-02
Next: SIGNATURE INNS INC/IN, 8-K, 1996-10-02




                      SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

                            WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549
                           ___________________________

                              AMENDMENT NO. 1 TO

                                SCHEDULE 14D-9
                 Solicitation/Recommendation Statement Pursuant to
               Section 14(d)(4) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
                           ___________________________

                                  BIG B, INC.
                           (Name of Subject Company)

                                 BIG B, INC.
                       (Name of Person Filing Statement)

                      COMMON STOCK, PAR VALUE $0.001 PER SHARE
                          (Title of Class of Securities)
                          ___________________________

                                   088891106
                     (CUSIP Number of Class of Securities)
                         ___________________________

                               ANTHONY J. BRUNO
                     CHAIRMAN AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
                                 BIG B, INC.
                            2600 MORGAN ROAD, S.E.
                              BESSEMER, AL 35023
                                 (205) 424-3421
               (Name, address and telephone number of person authorized
                  to receive notice and communications on behalf
                          of the person filing statement)
                          ___________________________

                                  COPIES TO:

             RICHARD COHN, ESQ.     AND      RANDALL H. DOUD, ESQ.
           SIROTE & PERMUTT, P.C.            SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE
         2222 ARLINGTON AVENUE SOUTH           MEAGHER & FLOM       
             BIRMINGHAM, AL 35205            919 THIRD AVENUE     
                  (205) 930-5130             NEW YORK, NY 10022    
                                             (212) 735-3000     


                    This statement amends and supplements the
          Solicitation/Recommendation Statement on Schedule 14D-9
          (the "Schedule 14D-9") of Big B, Inc., an Alabama
          corporation ("Big B"), filed with the Securities and
          Exchange Commission on September 23, 1996, with respect
          to the tender offer made by Revco D.S., Inc., a Delaware
          corporation ("Revco"), and RDS Acquisition Inc., a
          Delaware corporation and a wholly-owned subsidiary of
          Revco ("RDS Acquisition"), to purchase all outstanding
          shares of Big B Common Stock at a price of $15 per share,
          net to the seller in cash, upon the terms and subject to
          the conditions set forth in the Offer to Purchase, dated
          September 10, 1996, of Revco and RDS Acquisition and the
          related Letter of Transmittal of Revco and RDS
          Acquisition.

                    Capitalized terms used and not defined herein
          shall have the meanings ascribed to such terms in the
          Schedule 14D-9.

          ITEM 4. THE SOLICITATION OR RECOMMENDATION
          and 
          ITEM 7. CERTAIN NEGOTIATIONS AND TRANSACTIONS BY THE
          SUBJECT COMPANY

                    Beginning on September 23, 1996, Big B has
          entered into confidentiality agreements with a number of
          parties which have expressed interest in developing
          acquisition proposals for Big B.  Each of these
          confidentiality agreements was substantially in the form
          of the Confidentiality Agreement filed as Exhibit 7 to
          the Schedule 14D-9.  Pursuant to such confidentiality
          agreements, Big B has provided certain confidential
          financial information to each such interested party.  Big
          B has received preliminary, non-binding expressions of
          interest from certain of such parties at indicated values
          in excess of the $15.00 per share of Big B Common Stock
          contemplated by the Offer, and Big B expects to continue
          to provide confidential financial information to each
          such interested party.

                    On September 23, 1996, Big B sent to Revco a
          proposed confidentiality agreement in the form of the
          Confidentiality Agreement filed as Exhibit 7 to the
          Schedule 14D-9.  Between September 23, 1996 and September
          27, 1996, Big B and Revco, through their respective legal
          advisors, discussed various matters relating to the
          confidentiality agreement but did not reach an
          understanding as to terms that would be acceptable to
          both parties.

                    Late in the afternoon of September 27, 1996,
          Mr. D. Dwayne Hoven, President and Chief Executive
          Officer of Revco, sent a letter to Mr. Anthony J. Bruno,
          Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Big B, in which
          he objected to certain provisions of Big B's proposed
          confidentiality agreement and with which he provided
          Revco's proposed form of confidentiality agreement.

                    On October 1, 1996, Mr. Bruno sent the
          following letter to Mr. Hoven:

                                        October 2, 1996

               Mr. Dwayne Hoven
               President and Chief Executive Officer
               Revco D.S., Inc.
               1925 Enterprise Parkway
                    Twinsburg, Ohio 44087

               Dear Dwayne:

                         I am writing in response to your letter to
               me of September 27, 1996 with which you included
               your proposed revisions to the confidentiality
               agreement that I sent you on September 23, 1996.

                         As you know, one of Big B's objectives in
               the process that we have undertaken is to promote
               the interests of Big B's shareholders by seeking
               through confidentiality agreements to discourage
               potential acquirors of Big B from efforts to
               minimize the value available to Big B's shareholders
               through litigation pressure or other tactics.  If
               you are sincere in your repeatedly stated desire to
               work constructively with Big B, I encourage you to
               join the other interested parties who are proceeding
               consistent with this objective and promptly execute
               a confidentiality agreement on terms that Big B can
               accept.  Provided that a suitable agreement can be
               reached, I and the other members of the Big B Board
               of Directors would welcome Revco's active
               participation in the process.

                         In response to the specifics of your
               proposed confidentiality agreement, let me begin by
               noting that a number of other potentially interested
               parties have executed confidentiality agreements
               providing for the same standstill restrictions that
               were included in the proposed form of
               confidentiality agreement that I sent to you on
               September 23 and that no party other than Revco has
               advised Big B that it will not execute a
               confidentiality agreement because of reservations
               concerning such standstill provisions.  We believe
               that the responses from these parties, each of whom
               has expressed an interest in developing an
               acquisition proposal for Big B and is mindful that
               others are doing the same, clearly demonstrate that
               the standstill restrictions as proposed are entirely
               reasonable.

                         Even though what we have proposed has been
               found to be reasonable by all of the others, Big B
               would still prefer to reach a mutually acceptable
               confidentiality agreement with Revco.  In the
               interests of doing so, I am enclosing a revised form
               of confidentiality agreement that Big B is prepared
               to execute with Revco and which I believe
               appropriately balances Big B's and Revco's
               interests.  In order to preserve the level playing
               field for Revco and the other interested parties
               that we have sought to maintain, we will be
               communicating with each of the other parties with
               whom we have executed confidentiality agreements to
               offer to revise their agreements in accordance with
               the revised form being provided to you, whether or
               not we reach agreement with you.

                         Although the revised form of
               confidentiality agreement is self-explanatory,
               several points deserve emphasis:

                    *    We have retained the proposed December 15,
                         1996 termination date previously discussed
                         with your counsel rather than your
                         November 15 proposal.  The preliminary
                         results of the process Big B has
                         undertaken has confirmed us in our initial
                         judgment that the additional time may be
                         necessary for certain parties to formulate
                         their best proposals.  We have, however,
                         sought to address your other expressed
                         concerns by providing for an earlier
                         termination in the event that Big B enters
                         into a definitive and binding agreement to
                         be acquired or takes certain other
                         specified actions.

                    *    We continue to believe that pursuit by
                         Revco of rights plan litigation at this
                         juncture is clearly premature and would be
                         inimical to the process under which Big B
                         is seeking to develop and consider in an
                         orderly manner alternative proposals.  We
                         have accordingly proposed that such
                         litigation be stayed by both parties at
                         this time but have agreed that it could be
                         pursued once the termination date occurs.

                    *    We remain unwilling to include several Big
                         B covenants proposed by you because we
                         believe that they would generally have the
                         effect of inappropriately restricting the
                         Big B Board of Directors' ability to
                         comply with their fiduciary
                         responsibilities while potentially
                         chilling interest on the part of other
                         parties.  We have, however, sought to
                         address your stated concerns that Big B
                         not take certain kinds of actions while
                         Revco's actions are restricted by
                         accelerating the termination date under
                         the circumstances described above.  In any
                         event, neither the revised confidentiality
                         agreement nor the original proposed form
                         of confidentiality agreement would
                         restrict Revco's ability to seek judicial
                         redress (other than concerning the rights
                         plan as described above) at any time for
                         actions which are taken by Big B or the
                         Big B Board of Directors and which Revco
                         believes violates its legal rights.

                         I remain hopeful that you will see the
               benefits for Revco that an agreement promptly be
               reached which evidences Revco's willingness to be
               part of an orderly process and which affords Revco
               access to Big B's confidential financial
               information.  Whether or not Revco chooses to
               exclude itself from the confidential information, I
               assure you that the Big B Board of Directors will
               continue to act in the best interests of Big B's
               shareholders and will carefully consider any
               acquisition proposal that is timely received from
               Revco or any other party that appropriately reflects
               Big B's intrinsic value.

                                        Very truly yours,
                                        /s/ ANTHONY J. BRUNO

                                        Anthony J. Bruno
                                        Chairman of the Board and
                                        Chief Executive Officer

                    Included with such letter was a revised
          proposed form of confidentiality agreement (the "Revised
          Confidentiality Agreement").  A copy of the Revised
          Confidentiality Agreement is filed herewith as Exhibit 11
          and is incorporated herein by reference.

                    On October 2, 1996, Big B communicated to the
          various parties which had previously executed
          confidentiality agreements Big B's offer to revise their
          confidentiality agreements in accordance with the Revised
          Confidentiality Agreement.

          ITEM 8.  ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO BE FURNISHED

                    On September 23, 1996, Revco filed a notice of
          removal (the "Notice of Removal") removing the matter
          before the court in the action entitled Big B, Inc. v.
          Revco D.S., Inc. and RDS Acquisition Inc. (Circuit Court
          of Jefferson County, Alabama, Bessemer Division, C.A. No.
          CV-96-821) (the "Rights Plan Litigation"), concerning the
          validity of the Rights Plan, to the federal district
          court located in the Northern District of Alabama (the
          "District Court").

                    On September 24, 1996, Big B, Revco and RDS
          Acquisition reached an understanding regarding the
          information to be provided by Big B to Revco and RDS
          Acquisition pursuant to RDS Acquisition's demand pursuant
          to Section 16.02 of the Alabama Business Corporation Act
          to inspect Big B's securityholder lists and related
          corporate records.  Pursuant to such understanding, Big B
          has provided the agreed upon information to Revco and RDS
          Acquisition.

                    Late in the afternoon on September 30, 1996, in
          connection with the Rights Plan Litigation, Revco filed a
          counterclaim and a motion for a preliminary injunction in
          the District Court.  In such counterclaim, Revco
          challenges the validity of the Rights Plan and asserts
          that the Rights Plan violates Alabama law.  Specifically,
          the counterclaim alleges that the Rights Plan's
          provisions discriminating against certain holders of 10
          percent or more of the Big B Common Stock and allowing
          only the existing directors, and certain of their
          successors, to redeem the Rights issued under the Rights
          Plan illegally interfere with the rights of Big B
          shareholders.  Revco also asked the Federal Court to
          grant a preliminary injunction enjoining the Rights Plan
          from impeding the Offer.  Big B intends to vigorously
          defend against such actions.  The complete text of such
          counterclaim and motion for preliminary injunction have
          been filed as an exhibit to Amendment No. 4 to Revco's
          Tender Offer Statement on Schedule 14D-1.  

                    On October 1, 1996, Big B filed a motion to
          remand (the "Motion to Remand") with the District Court
          seeking to remand the Rights Plan Litigation to the
          Circuit Court of Jefferson County, Alabama, Bessemer
          Division.  A copy of the Motion to Remand is filed
          herewith as Exhibit 12 and is incorporated herein by
          reference.

          ITEM 9.   MATERIAL TO BE FILED AS EXHIBITS.

               The following Exhibits are filed herewith:

          Exhibit 11:    Form of Revised Confidentiality Agreement

          Exhibit 12:    Motion to Remand


                                  SIGNATURE

                    After reasonable inquiry and to the best of his
          knowledge and belief, the undersigned certifies that the
          information set forth in this Statement is true, complete
          and correct.

                                      BIG B, INC.

                                      By: /s/ ARTHUR M. JONES, SR. 
                                      Name:  Arthur M. Jones, Sr.
                                      Title: President and Chief
                                             Operating Officer

          Dated:    October 2, 1996


                                 Exhibit Index

                                                               Page

          Exhibit 11:    Form of Revised Confidentiality
                         Agreement

          Exhibit 12:    Motion to Remand





                                                         EXHIBIT 11

                                 BIG B, INC.
                            2600 Morgan Road S.E.
                            Bessemer, Alabama 35023

                                        October 1, 1996

          Revco D.S., Inc.
          1925 Enterprise Parkway
          Twinsburg, Ohio 44087

          Attention:  Mr. D. Dwayne Hoven

                          CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT

                    Revco D.S., Inc. has requested that Big B, Inc.
          (the "Company") furnish it with certain information as it
          may reasonably request relating to the Company which is
          non-public, confidential and proprietary in nature in
          connection with its proposed transaction with the Company
          (the "Transaction").  All such information (whether
          written or oral) furnished (whether before or after the
          date hereof) by the Company or its directors, officers,
          employees, affiliates, representatives (including, with-
          out limitation, financial advisors, attorneys and accoun-
          tants) or agents (collectively, "our Representatives") to
          you and your directors, officers, employees, affiliates,
          representatives (including, without limitation, financial
          advisors, attorneys, proxy solicitors, public relations
          consultants and accountants) or agents (collectively,
          "your Representatives") and all analyses, compilations,
          forecasts, studies or other notes or documents prepared
          by you or your Representatives which contain or reflect,
          or are generated from, any such information is hereinaf-
          ter referred to as the "Information."  The term Informa-
          tion will not, however, include (i) information which is
          already in your possession (other than information pro-
          vided to you or your Representatives by the Company),
          (ii) information which is or becomes publicly available
          other than as a result of a disclosure by you or your
          Representative in breach of this Agreement, (iii) infor-
          mation which is or becomes available to you on a noncon-
          fidential basis from a source (other than the Company or
          our Representatives) which, to the best of your knowledge
          after due inquiry, is not prohibited from disclosing such
          information to you by a legal, contractual, fiduciary or
          other obligation to the Company, (iv) is or becomes
          available to you on a nonconfidential basis from the
          Company or its Representatives pursuant to statutory or
          other legal rights to inspect or receive information or
          (v) any analysis or other documents prepared by you or
          your Representatives from the information described in
          clauses (i), (ii), (iii) or (iv), above.
          As a condition to, and in consideration of the Company
          providing you with Information, you acknowledge and agree
          as follows:

          1.   You and your Representatives (i) will keep the
               Information confidential and will not (except as
               required by applicable law, regulation or legal
               process, and only after compliance with paragraph 2
               below), without our prior written consent, disclose
               any Information in any manner whatsoever, and (ii)
               will not use any Information other than in connec-
               tion with the Transaction.  You further agree to
               disclose the Information only to your Representa-
               tives (a) who need to know the Information in con-
               nection with negotiating or evaluating the Transac-
               tion, (b) who are informed by you of the confiden-
               tial nature of the Information and (c) who have
               agreed to be bound by the terms of this letter
               agreement.  You agree to prepare a list of those
               individuals and entities to whom any Information has
               been disclosed and present the list to the Company
               promptly upon request.  The Company will keep the
               list confidential.  Notwithstanding any provision to
               the contrary contained herein, you shall be permit-
               ted to disclose such of the Information as you are
               advised by counsel is legally required to be dis-
               closed under the United States securities laws, and
               paragraph 2 shall not apply to such disclosure.  You
               agree that you will be responsible for any breach of
               this letter agreement by any of your Representa-
               tives.

          2.   In the event that you or any of your Representatives
               are requested or required (by oral questions, inter-
               rogations, requests for information documents,
               subpoena, civil investigative demand, any informal
               or formal investigation by any government or govern-
               mental agency or authority or otherwise) to disclose
               any of the Information (other than in any litigation
               between the Company, or any of its Representatives,
               on the one hand, and you or any of your Representa-
               tives, on the other hand), you will notify the
               Company promptly in writing so that we may seek a
               protective order or other appropriate remedy or, in
               our sole discretion, waive compliance with the terms
               of this letter agreement.  You agree not to oppose
               any action by the Company to obtain a protective
               order or other appropriate remedy.  In the event
               that no such protective order or other remedy is
               obtained, or that the Company waives compliance with
               the terms of this letter agreement, you agree that
               you will furnish only that portion of the Informa-
               tion which you are advised by counsel is legally
               required.

          3.   You shall keep a record of each location of the
               Information.  You agree, immediately upon a request
               from the Company, to return to the Company all 
               Information, and no copies, extracts or other repro-
               ductions of the Information shall be retained by you
               or your Representatives.  Any portion of the Infor-
               mation that consists solely of analyses, compila-
               tions, forecasts, schedules or other notes or docu-
               ments prepared by you or your Representatives, in
               lieu of being returned to the Company, may be de-
               stroyed by you or such Representative, in which
               event one of your authorized officers shall provide
               certification to the Company that materials have in
               fact been so destroyed; provided, however, that your
               financial advisors and legal advisors may retain for
               their files, in accordance with their usual prac-
               tice, one copy of any Information prepared by them.
               Any oral Information that is retained by you or your
               Representatives will continue to be subject to this
               letter agreement.

          4.   You acknowledge that none of the Company, nor our
               Representatives, nor any of our or their respective
               officers, directors, employees, agents or control-
               ling persons within the meaning of Section 20 of the
               Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the
               "Exchange Act"), makes any express or implied repre-
               sentation or warranty as to the accuracy or com-
               pleteness of the Information, and you agree, to the
               fullest extent permitted by law, that no such person
               will have any liability to you or any of your Repre-
               sentatives on any basis (including, without limita-
               tion, in contract or tort, under federal or state
               securities laws or otherwise) with respect to the
               Transaction as a result of this letter agreement,
               your participation in evaluating the Transaction,
               your review of the Company, the use of the Informa-
               tion by you or your representatives, or any errors
               therein or omission from the Information.  Nothing
               in the foregoing provision shall be deemed to waive
               or limit in any respect any rights or claims you may
               have based on any actual or alleged breaches of the
               fiduciary duties owed by the Company's Board of
               Directors to the Company and its shareholders.  You
               further agree that you are not entitled to rely on
               the accuracy or completeness of the Information and
               that you will be entitled to rely solely on such
               representations and warranties as may be included in
               any definitive agreement with respect to the Trans-
               action, subject to such limitations and restrictions
               as may be contained therein.

          5.   You acknowledge that you are aware, and you will
               advise your Representatives who are informed of the
               matters that are the subject of this letter agree-
               ment, of the restrictions imposed by the United
               States securities laws on the purchase or sale of
               securities by any person who has received material,
               non-public information from the issuer of such
               securities, which may include certain portions of
               the Information, and on the communication of such
               information to any other person.

          6.   You agree that, from the date of this Agreement
               through the Termination Date (as defined below),
               neither you nor any of your affiliates will, without
               the prior written consent of the Company:  (i)
               acquire, offer to acquire, or agree to acquire,
               directly or indirectly, by purchase or otherwise,
               any voting securities or direct or indirect rights
               to acquire any voting securities of the Company;
               (ii) make, or in any way participate in, directly or
               indirectly, any "solicitation" of "proxies" (as such
               terms are used in the rules of the Securities and
               Exchange Commission) whether before or after the
               formal commencement of any such solicitation, or
               seek to advise or influence any person or entity
               with respect to the voting of, any voting securities
               of the Company; (iii) call, or seek to call, a
               meeting of the Company's shareholders or execute any
               written consent or initiate any shareholder proposal
               for action by shareholders of the Company; (iv)
               otherwise act, alone or in concert with others, to
               seek to acquire control of the Company or influence
               the Board of Directors, management or policies of
               the Company; (v) bring any action, or otherwise act
               through judicial process, to contest the validity of
               the Company's shareholder rights plan or to seek the
               redemption of the rights issued thereunder; or (vi)
               induce any other person or entity to do any of the
               foregoing; provided, however, that the foregoing
               shall not prevent (x) any cash tender offer for all
               the outstanding shares of common stock, par value
               $0.001 per share, of the Company at a price of not
               less than $15 per share, and any filings required in
               connection therewith, (y) any transaction approved
               by the Company's Board of Directors or (z) any
               action or other legal proceeding to enforce this
               Agreement.  In furtherance of the agreement set
               forth in clause (v) above, the Company and you agree
               to seek from the relevant courts a stay of the
               proceedings in the action entitled Big B, Inc. v.
               Revco D.S., Inc. and RDS Acquisition Inc. in the
               Circuit Court of Jefferson County, Alabama, Bessemer
               Division as removed to the United States District
               Court for the Northern District Court of Alabama,
               Southern Division, and to take no action to seek a
               lifting of such stay until the Termination Date. 
               For purposes of this Agreement, "Termination Date"
               shall mean the earliest to occur of (w) December 15,
               1996, (x) the execution by the Company of a defini-
               tive and binding agreement providing for the acqui-
               sition of the Company, (y) the adoption of any
               amendment to the Company's existing shareholder
               rights plan in any manner adverse to you or the
               adoption of any new shareholder rights plan, or (z)
               any public announcement by the Company of any pro-
               posal to amend its articles of incorporation.

          7.   (a)  You agree that either party will be irreparably
                    injured by a breach of this letter agreement by
                    the other party or its Representatives, that
                    monetary remedies are inadequate to protect
                    against any actual or threatened breach of this
                    letter agreement by either party or by its
                    Representatives, and that either party shall be
                    entitled to specific performance or other equi-
                    table relief as a remedy for any breach.  Such
                    remedy shall not be deemed to be the exclusive
                    remedy for a breach of this letter agreement
                    but shall be in addition to all other remedies
                    available at law or equity.

               (b)  It is further agreed that no failure or delay
                    in exercising any right, power or privilege
                    hereunder will operate as a waiver thereof, nor
                    will any single or partial exercise thereof
                    preclude any other or further exercise thereof
                    or the exercise of any right, power or privi-
                    lege hereunder.

               (c)  This letter agreement will be governed by and
                    construed in accordance with the laws of the
                    State of Alabama, without regard to the princi-
                    ples of conflict of laws thereof.

               (d)  This letter agreement contains the entire
                    agreement between you and us concerning the
                    subject matter hereof and supersedes all previ-
                    ous agreements, written or oral, relating to
                    the subject matter hereof.  No modifications of
                    this letter agreement or waiver of the terms
                    and conditions hereof will be binding upon you
                    or us, unless approved in writing by each of
                    you and us.

               (e)  If any provision of this letter agreement shall
                    for any reason, be adjudged by any court of
                    competent jurisdiction to be invalid or unen-
                    forceable, such judgment shall not affect,
                    impair or invalidate the remainder of this
                    letter agreement but shall be confined in its
                    operation to the provision of this agreement
                    directly involved in the controversy in which
                    such judgment shall have been rendered.

               (f)  This letter agreement may be executed in coun-
                    terparts, each of which shall be deemed to be
                    an original, but both of which shall constitute
                    the same agreement.

               (g)  This letter agreement shall inure to the bene-
                    fit of and be binding upon our respective suc-
                    cessors and assigns; provided, however, that
                    neither this letter agreement nor any of the
                    rights, interests or obligations hereunder
                    shall be assigned by either of us without the
                    prior written consent of the other party.

               (h)  All notices hereunder shall be made in writing,
                    by first class mail, by courier or by
                    telecopier (with a confirming copy sent by
                    first class mail) to, in the case of the Compa-
                    ny, Big B, Inc., Attention: Chief Executive
                    Officer, 2600 Morgan Road S.E., Bessemer, Ala-
                    bama 35023, telecopier: (205) 425-3525, or, in
                    the case of you, Revco D.S., Inc., Attention:
                    President and Chief Executive Officer, 1925
                    Enterprise Parkway, Twinsburg, Ohio 44087,
                    telecopier: (216) 487-1679.

          Please confirm your agreement with the foregoing by
          signing and returning to the undersigned the duplicate
          copy of this letter enclosed herewith.

                                        Very truly yours,

                                        Big B, Inc.

                                        By:_____________________
                                           Name: 
                                           Title: 

          Accepted and Agreed
          as of the date first
          written above:

          Revco D.S., Inc.

          By:_____________________
             Name:
             Title:






                                                            EXHIBIT 12

          IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
          FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ALABAMA
          SOUTHERN DIVISION

          BIG B, INC.,                      )
                                            )      CIVIL ACTION NO:
               Plaintiff,                   )      CV-96-H-2496-S
                                            )
          v.                                )
                                            )
          REVCO D.S. INC., and              )
          RDS ACQUISITION, INC.,            )
                                            )
               Defendants.                  )

                               MOTION TO REMAND

                    The Plaintiff, Big B, Inc. ("Big B") moves this
          Court to remand this action to the Circuit Court for
          Jefferson County, Alabama, Bessemer Division.  In support
          of this Motion to Remand, Big B states as follows:

                    1.   This action was commenced by the filing of
          a Verified Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief
          ("Complaint") on September 23, 1996.  This action was
          removed by Defendants Revco D.S., Inc. ("Revco") and RDS
          Acquisition Inc. ("RDS") by filing of a Notice of Removal
          in this Court on September 23, 1996.  The sole basis for
          federal subject matter jurisdiction alleged in the Notice
          of Removal is that this Court has jurisdiction based on
          the diversity of the parties and because the amount in
          controversy exceeds $50,000.

                    2.   The Complaint requests construction of a
          Shareholder Rights Plan ("Rights Plan") adopted by the Big
          B Board of Directors.  No federal statute is at issue in
          this case.

                    3.   Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. SECTION 1441 and 28 U.S.C.
          SECTION 1332, federal diversity subject matter jurisdiction only
          exists in this case if the amount in controversy exceeds
          the sum of $50,000, exclusive of interest and costs.

                    4.   The $50,000 amount in controversy require-
          ment is not satisfied in this case.  The relief requested
          by Big B is purely equitable in nature and concerns only a
          determination of the validity of the Rights Plan as adopt-
          ed by the Board of Directors.

                    5.   Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. SECTION 1447(c), this
          Motion for Remand has been filed within thirty (30) days
          after the filing of the Notice of Removal.

                    6.   In support of this Motion, Big B submits
          its brief, attached hereto as Exhibit "A."


                    WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, Big B respect-
          fully requests that this Court enter an order remanding
          this case to the Circuit Court for Jefferson County,
          Alabama, Bessemer Division.

                                        Respectfully submitted,

                                        /s/ KAYE H. TURBERVILLE
                                        ----------------------------
                                        KAYE H. TURBERVILLE (HOU002)
                                        SAMUEL M. HILL (HIL025)
                                        MICHAEL A. CATALANO (CAT010)

                                        Attorneys for Big B, Inc.

          OF Counsel:
          SIROTE & PERMUTT, P.C.
          2222 Arlington Avenue S.
          P.O. Box 55727
          Birmingham, AL  35255-5727
          (205) 933-7111


                            CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

                    I certify that a copy of the above foregoing
          instrument was served on the following counsel of record
          BY HAND DELIVERY this   1   day of October, 1996.

                    Hobart A. McWhorter, Jr., Esq.
                    Phillip A. Carroll, III, Esq.
                    Matthew A. Aiken, Esq.
                    BRADLEY, ARANT, ROSE & WHITE
                    P.O. Box 830709
                    Birmingham, AL  35283-0709

                                        /s/ KAYE H. TURBERVILLE
                                        ----------------------------
                                        OF COUNSEL




© 2022 IncJournal is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission