RENT WAY INC
S-3, 2000-06-01
EQUIPMENT RENTAL & LEASING, NEC
Previous: MEDIX RESOURCES INC, 8-K, EX-99, 2000-06-01
Next: RENT WAY INC, S-3, EX-5.(1), 2000-06-01





      As filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on June 1, 2000

                                             Registration No. 333-________


                     U.S. SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
                             Washington, D.C. 20549

                                   ----------
                                    FORM S-3

             REGISTRATION STATEMENT UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933
                                   ----------
                                 RENT-WAY, INC.

             (Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)

                Pennsylvania                         25-1407782
              (State or other                     (I.R.S. Employer
      jurisdiction of incorporation or            Identification No.)
               organization)

                                One RentWay Place
                            Erie, Pennsylvania 16505
                                 (814) 455-5378
               (Address, including zip code, and telephone number,
        including area code, of registrant's principal executive offices)

                 William E. Morgenstern, Chief Executive Officer
                                One RentWay Place
                            Erie, Pennsylvania 16505
                                 (814) 455-5378
            (Name, address, including zip code, and telephone number,
                   including area code, of agent for service)

                                   ----------
                                    Copy to:

                                John J. Zak, Esq.
                              Paul J. Vallone, Esq.
                  Hodgson, Russ, Andrews, Woods & Goodyear, LLP
                           One M & T Plaza, Suite 2000
                             Buffalo, New York 14203

                                    ---------

     Approximate date of commencement of proposed sale to the public:  from time
to time after this Registration Statement becomes effective.

<PAGE>

     If the only securities on this Form are being offered  pursuant to dividend
or interest reinvestment plans, please check the following box: o

     If any of the securities being registered on this Form are to be offered on
a delayed or continuous  basis  pursuant to Rule 415 under the Securities Act of
1933, other than securities offered only in connection with dividend or interest
reinvestment plans, check the following box: X

     If the Form is filed to  register  additional  securities  for an  offering
pursuant to Rule 462(b) under the Securities Act, please check the following box
and list  the  Securities  Act  registration  statement  number  of the  earlier
effective registration statement for the same offering. ___   _________________.

     If this Form is a  post-effective  amendment  filed pursuant to Rule 462(c)
under the  Securities  Act,  check the following box and list the Securities Act
registration  statement number of the earlier effective  registration  statement
for the same offering. ___   __________________.

     If delivery of the  prospectus is expected to be made pursuant to Rule 434,
please check the following box. ___

                                       2
<PAGE>

<TABLE>
<CAPTION>
                                CALCULATION OF REGISTRATION FEE
                                -------------------------------
<S>                     <C>            <C>                   <C>                  <C>
Title of each class     Amount to be   Proposed maximum      Proposed maximum     Amount of
of securities to be     registered     offering price per    aggregate offering   registration fee
registered                                                   price
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Common Stock,
without par value       115,812 (1)    $25.469 (2)           $2,949,616 (2)       $779
===================     ============   ===================   ==================   =================

</TABLE>

(1)  Represents  shares of common  stock  underlying  stock  options held by the
     selling shareholders.

(2)  Estimated  solely for  purposes  of  calculating  the  registration  fee in
     accordance with Rule 457(c) based on the average of the high and low prices
     for the shares of common  stock as reported on the New York Stock  Exchange
     on May 25, 2000.

     The Registrant  hereby amends this  Registration  Statement on such date or
dates as may be necessary to delay its effective date until the Registrant shall
file a further  amendment  which  specifically  states  that  this  Registration
Statement shall  thereafter  become effective in accordance with Section 8(a) of
the  Securities  Act of 1933 or until the  Registration  Statement  shall become
effective on such date as the Commission,  acting pursuant to said Section 8(a),
may determine.

                                       3
<PAGE>

                                   PROSPECTUS

                                 RENT-WAY, INC.

                         115,812 SHARES OF COMMON STOCK

     This prospectus relates to the public offering by the selling  shareholders
listed in this  prospectus  of 115,812  shares of our common  stock.  The common
stock is being offered for the account of the selling  shareholders  and we will
not receive any proceeds from this offering.

     The common stock  offered by the selling  shareholders  consists of 115,812
shares of our common stock underlying options granted to the former shareholders
of McKenzie  Leasing  Corporation in connection with our acquisition of McKenzie
Leasing Corporation in July 1995. The selling shareholders purchased the options
from the former McKenzie Leasing Corporation  shareholders on or about April 12,
2000.  Our common stock is traded on the NYSE under the symbol "RWY." On May 30,
2000,  the last sale price of the common  stock,  as reported  by the NYSE,  was
$26.75 per share.

     INVESTING IN THE COMMON STOCK INVOLVES  CERTAIN  RISKS.  SEE "RISK FACTORS"
BEGINNING ON PAGE 6 FOR A DISCUSSION OF THESE RISKS.

     THE SELLING  SHAREHOLDERS AND ANY BROKER EXECUTING SELLING ORDERS ON BEHALF
OF THE SELLING  SHAREHOLDERS MAY BE DEEMED TO BE AN  "UNDERWRITER."  COMMISSIONS
RECEIVED BY ANY BROKER MAY BE DEEMED TO BE UNDERWRITING COMMISSIONS.

     NEITHER THE  SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE  COMMISSION  NOR ANY STATE  SECURITIES
COMMISSION HAS APPROVED OR DISAPPROVED OF THESE SECURITIES OR DETERMINED IF THIS
PROSPECTUS  IS TRUTHFUL OR  COMPLETE.  ANY  REPRESENTATION  TO THE CONTRARY IS A
CRIMINAL OFFENSE.

     THE DATE OF THIS PROSPECTUS IS JUNE 1, 2000

                                       4
<PAGE>


                                TABLE OF CONTENTS

Rent-Way, Inc. .....................................................  6
Risk Factors .......................................................  6
Use of Proceeds .................................................... 20
Selling Shareholders ............................................... 20
Plan of Distribution ............................................... 21
Legal Matters ...................................................... 22
Experts ............................................................ 22
About this Prospectus .............................................. 23
Where You Can Find More Information ................................ 23





                                       5
<PAGE>

                                 RENT-WAY, INC.

     Rent-Way, Inc. (the "Company" or "Rent-Way") is the second largest operator
in the rental  purchase  industry with 1,094 stores in 42 states.  We offer home
entertainment equipment,  furniture,  major appliances,  electronics,  computers
(with  pre-paid  internet  access) and jewelry to customers  under  full-service
rental-purchase agreements that generally allow the customer to obtain ownership
of the merchandise at the conclusion of an agreed upon rental period. We believe
that these rental-purchase arrangements appeal to a wide variety of customers by
allowing  them to obtain  merchandise  that they  might  otherwise  be unable or
unwilling  to obtain due to  insufficient  cash  resources  or lack of access to
credit or because they have a temporary,  short-term need for the merchandise or
a desire to rent rather than purchase the merchandise.

     Our principal  executive  offices are located at One RentWay  Place,  Erie,
Pennsylvania 16505, and our telephone number is (814) 455-5378.

                                  RISK FACTORS

     YOU SHOULD  CAREFULLY  CONSIDER THE RISKS DESCRIBED BELOW BEFORE YOU DECIDE
TO BUY OUR COMMON  STOCK.  IF ANY OF THE FOLLOWING  RISKS  ACTUALLY  OCCUR,  OUR
BUSINESS,  FINANCIAL CONDITION AND RESULTS OF OPERATIONS WOULD LIKELY SUFFER. IN
SUCH CASE, THE TRADING PRICE OF OUR COMMON STOCK COULD DECLINE.

     CERTAIN  STATEMENTS  MADE IN THIS  PROSPECTUS,  AND OTHER  WRITTEN  OR ORAL
STATEMENTS  MADE  BY  US OR  ON  OUR  BEHALF,  MAY  CONSTITUTE  "FORWARD-LOOKING
STATEMENTS" WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE FEDERAL SECURITIES LAWS. WHEN USED IN THIS
PROSPECTUS, THE WORDS "BELIEVES," "EXPECTS," "ESTIMATES," "INTENDS," AND SIMILAR
EXPRESSIONS  ARE  INTENDED TO IDENTIFY  FORWARD-LOOKING  STATEMENTS.  STATEMENTS
REGARDING FUTURE EVENTS AND DEVELOPMENTS AND OUR FUTURE PERFORMANCE,  AS WELL AS
OUR EXPECTATIONS,  BELIEFS, PLANS, INTENTIONS, ESTIMATES OR PROJECTIONS RELATING
TO THE FUTURE, ARE FORWARD-LOOKING  STATEMENTS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THESE LAWS.
EXAMPLES OF SUCH STATEMENTS IN THIS PROSPECTUS INCLUDE DESCRIPTIONS OF OUR PLANS
TO OPEN NEW STORES, OUR PLANS FOR ADDING COMPUTERS TO OUR PRODUCT SELECTIONS AND
OUR ADDITION OF THE PRE-PAID LOCAL TELEPHONE  EXCHANGE  SERVICES  BUSINESS.  ALL
FORWARD-LOOKING  STATEMENTS ARE SUBJECT TO CERTAIN RISKS AND UNCERTAINTIES  THAT
COULD CAUSE ACTUAL EVENTS TO DIFFER MATERIALLY FROM THOSE PROJECTED.  WE BELIEVE
THAT THESE  FORWARD-LOOKING  STATEMENTS ARE REASONABLE;  HOWEVER, YOU SHOULD NOT
PLACE UNDUE RELIANCE ON SUCH  STATEMENTS.  THESE STATEMENTS ARE BASED ON CURRENT
EXPECTATIONS AND SPEAK ONLY AS OF THE DATE OF SUCH  STATEMENTS.  WE UNDERTAKE NO
OBLIGATION TO PUBLICLY UPDATE OR REVISE ANY FORWARD-LOOKING  STATEMENT,  WHETHER
AS A RESULT OF FUTURE EVENTS, NEW INFORMATION OR OTHERWISE.

WE MAY BE UNABLE TO  ACQUIRE  NEW STORES  SUCCESSFULLY,  WHICH  WOULD  LIMIT OUR
GROWTH AND MATERIALLY ADVERSELY AFFECT OUR RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

                                       6
<PAGE>

     Our  continued  growth  will  depend,  in part,  on our  ability to acquire
additional   rental-purchase   stores  on  favorable  terms,  to  enhance  their
performance and to integrate the acquired  stores into our  operations.  We will
compete  for  acquisition  opportunities  with  other  companies  one of  which,
Rent-A-Center,  has significantly  greater financial and other resources.  There
can be no  assurance  that  we  will  be able  to  locate  or  acquire  suitable
acquisition  candidates,  that  acquisition  candidates,  once  located,  can be
acquired by us on terms  comparable  with terms available to  Rent-A-Center,  or
that  any  operations  that  are  acquired  can be  effectively  and  profitably
integrated into our existing  operations.  Furthermore,  future acquisitions may
negatively  impact  our  operating  results,  particularly  during  the  periods
immediately  following  an  acquisition.  We may  acquire  operations  that  are
unprofitable or have  inconsistent  profitability.  The inability to improve the
profitability  of these acquired stores could have a material  adverse effect on
our results of operations and financial  condition.  Our acquisition strategy is
also likely to place  significant  demands on our  management  and our financial
resources.

WE MAY BE UNABLE TO OPEN NEW STORES  SUCCESSFULLY,  WHICH WOULD LIMIT OUR GROWTH
AND MATERIALLY ADVERSELY AFFECT OUR RESULTS OF OPERATIONS.

     We have  announced an aggressive  plan to open 400 new stores over the next
three to four years. Our inability to open these new stores and have them become
profitable in a timely manner or at all could  materially  adversely  affect our
results of operations.

WE MAY BE UNABLE TO IMPROVE  FURTHER THE  PROFITABILITY  OF THE STORES  ACQUIRED
FROM HOME CHOICE HOLDINGS,  INC.,  WHICH COULD NEGATIVELY  AFFECT OUR RESULTS OF
OPERATIONS

     Our  continued  profitability  growth will depend on our ability to improve
further the revenue performance and profitability of the stores we acquired from
Home  Choice  Holdings,   Inc.  in  December  1998.  Our  inability  to  improve
profitability and performance  further could negatively affect on our results of
operations.

OUR GROWTH STRATEGY REQUIRES SIGNIFICANT CONTINUING CASH INVESTMENT

     Our cash  requirements  have been and will continue to be  significant.  In
connection  with a new program  recently  entered into with  Gateway  Companies,
Inc.,  we have  agreed  to  purchase  all of the  computers  that are  rented to
customers from Gateway which will require a significant  annual cash investment.
As part of our recent  acquisition of dPi  TeleConnect,  LLC, and our entry into
the business of providing  local  telephone  exchange  services,  we will invest
significant  cash to grow  this  business.  Also,  as  part of our  strategy  to
continue to grow  through  opening new store  locations,  we will be required to
invest  significant   amounts  of  cash.  In  addition  to  capital  needed  for
acquisitions,  new store  openings,  additional  purchases of computers  and the
local telephone  exchange services  business,  we will also need cash to service
our current  debt,  and for the  purchase of new rental  merchandise.  We cannot
assure that adequate capital will be available to us on acceptable terms.

WE HAVE INCURRED SUBSTANTIAL DEBT IN PURSUING OUR GROWTH STRATEGY

     We have incurred  substantial  indebtedness to finance acquisitions and new
store openings.  We had debt of approximately $312 million at March 31, 2000 and
our ratio of debt to total shareholders'  equity was approximately 98%. At March
31, 1999 and March 31, 1998, our ratio of debt to total shareholders' equity was
80% and 72%, respectively. We cannot assure you that we will have the ability to
service our debt.  Nor can we assure you that we will be able to  refinance  our
debt at maturity on terms that are acceptable to us.

                                       7
<PAGE>

A  SUBSTANTIAL  PORTION OF OUR ASSETS  CONSIST OF INTANGIBLE  ASSETS,  PRIMARILY
GOODWILL

     A substantial portion of our assets consist of intangible assets, including
goodwill  and  covenants  not  to  compete   relating  to  the   acquisition  of
rental-purchase  stores.  At March 31, 2000,  we had $312 million of  intangible
assets of these types, a substantial portion of our $673 million in total assets
at that date. We expect  goodwill on our balance sheet to increase in the future
in connection  with  additional  acquisitions.  These additions to goodwill will
have an  adverse  impact on  earnings  as  goodwill  will be  amortized  against
earnings.  We cannot assure you that in the event of any sale or  liquidation of
Rent-Way,  the  value of  Rent-Way's  intangible  assets  will be  realized.  In
addition, we evaluate continually whether events and circumstances have occurred
that indicate the remaining balance of intangible assets are recoverable. We may
be required to reduce the carrying  value of our  intangible  assets if and when
factors indicate that these  intangible  assets should be evaluated for possible
impairment. This type of reduction could materially adversely affect our results
of operations.

THE RENTAL PURCHASE INDUSTRY IS SUBJECT TO SIGNIFICANT GOVERNMENT REGULATION

     Forty-seven states have enacted laws regulating or otherwise  impacting the
rental-purchase  transaction,  including  all the states in which our stores are
located.  These laws generally require specific written  disclosures  concerning
the nature of the transaction and also provide  consumer  protection,  such as a
grace period for late  payments and contract  reinstatement  rights in the event
the rental-purchase agreement is terminated for non-payment. The rental-purchase
laws  of  some  states,   including  California,   Michigan,   New  York,  Ohio,
Pennsylvania  and West  Virginia  limit the total dollar amount of payments that
may be charged over the life of the rental-purchase  agreement. As we acquire or
open new stores in states in which we do not currently  operate,  we will become
subject  to  rental-purchase  laws  of  those  states.  We  cannot  provide  any
assurances  against the  enactment of new or revised  rental  purchase laws that
could materially adversely affect us.

     No federal  legislation has been enacted regulating or otherwise  impacting
the  rental-purchase  transaction.  From  time-to-time,   legislation  has  been
introduced  in Congress  that would  regulate the  rental-purchase  transaction,
including  legislation  that would  subject the  transaction  to interest  rate,
finance charge and fee limitations, and to the Federal Truth in Lending Act. Any
federal legislation of this sort, if enacted,  could materially adversely affect
us.

THE RENTAL-PURCHASE INDUSTRY IS HIGHLY COMPETITIVE

     The rental-purchase  industry is highly competitive.  We compete with other
rental-purchase  businesses and, to a lesser extent,  with rental stores that do
not offer their customers a purchase  option.  Competition is based primarily on
rental  prices and terms,  product  selection  and  availability,  and  customer
service.  We also  compete with  department  stores,  discount  stores and other
retail  outlets  that offer an  installment  sales  program or offer  comparable
products and prices. Our largest industry competitor, Rent-A-Center, is national
in scope and has  significantly  greater  financial and operating  resources and
greater name recognition than we have. We cannot assure you that we will be able
to  successfully  compete  with  Rent-A-Center  or with our  other  competitors.
Furthermore,  additional  competitors may emerge,  especially  since the cost of
entering the rental-purchase business is relatively low.

                                       8
<PAGE>

WE DEPEND ON OUR KEY PERSONNEL

     Our operations and future success are largely  dependent upon our executive
officers.  The  loss  of  services  of any of  these  executive  officers  could
materially adversely affect us.

WE HAVE ADOPTED CERTAIN ANTI-TAKEOVER PROVISIONS THAT COULD DETER A TAKEOVER

     Our Articles of Incorporation and By-laws contain provisions that could
delay, deter or prevent a merger,  tender offer or other business combination or
change  in  control  involving  the  Company  that  some  or a  majority  of our
shareholders  might consider to be in their best interest,  including  offers or
attempted  takeovers that might result in our  shareholders  receiving a premium
over the then market price of their common stock.  Our Articles of Incorporation
contain a provision  authorizing the issuance of "blank check"  preferred stock.
Our By-laws contain provisions  establishing a classified Board of Directors and
advance notice requirements for director  nominations and actions to be taken at
annual  shareholder  meetings.  The By-laws also provide that only the directors
may call special  meetings of the  shareholders and that the Board, or any class
of the Board or any  individual  director,  may be removed  from office only for
cause and only by vote of holders of greater than 50% of the outstanding  common
stock.

                                       9
<PAGE>

                                    BUSINESS
General

     We were formed in Erie,  Pennsylvania  in 1981 and have been engaged in the
rental-purchase  business since our formation. We currently operate 1,094 stores
that provide brand name merchandise in 42 states.  We offer quality,  brand name
home  entertainment  equipment,   furniture,   major  appliances,   electronics,
computers  (with  pre-paid  internet  access)  and  jewelry to  customers  under
full-service  rental-purchase  agreements  that generally  allow the customer to
obtain  ownership of the  merchandise at the conclusion of an agreed upon rental
period.  We believe  that these  rental-purchase  arrangements  appeal to a wide
variety of  customers  by allowing  them to obtain  merchandise  that they might
otherwise be unable or unwilling to obtain due to insufficient cash resources or
lack of access to credit or because they have a temporary,  short-term  need for
the merchandise or a desire to rent rather than purchase the merchandise.

     Our principal  executive  offices are located at One RentWay  Place,  Erie,
Pennsylvania 16505, and our telephone number is (814) 455-5378.

Recent Developments

     On May 1, 2000, we entered into an agreement with Gateway  Companies,  Inc.
pursuant to which Gateway will be our exclusive  supplier of personal  computers
as long as we purchase a specified  number of computers  from Gateway during the
first 18 months of the agreement. As part of this transaction, Gateway purchased
348,910 shares of our common stock for $7.0 million.

     On  January  4,  2000,  we  acquired  a  49%  ownership   interest  in  dPi
TeleConnect, LLC, a company engaged in the business of providing local telephone
exchange services, for a total purchase price of $6.4 million. Once all required
regulatory  consents are  obtained  for the change in majority  ownership of dPi
TeleConnect,  which we anticipate  will occur in early May 2000, we will acquire
an additional 21% interest in dPi TeleConnect for an additional $1.1 million.

     dPi TeleConnect  offers  pre-paid local phone service without  reference to
prior credit history or payment history with a local phone company.  The service
is paid for in advance and requires no long-term  obligation  on the part of the
customer.   We  believe  that  the  acquisition  of  dPi  TeleConnect   provides
substantial new growth  opportunities  for us both through our  participation in
its  revenues  and  profits  and  through  its  ability  to drive new  potential
customers to our rental-purchase stores for the purchase of pre-paid local phone
services.

The Rental-Purchase Industry

     Begun  in  the  mid-to-late  1960s,  the  rental-purchase   business  is  a
relatively  new  segment of the  retail  industry  offering  an  alternative  to
traditional  retail  installment  sales. The  rental-purchase  industry provides
brand  name   merchandise   to  customers   generally  on  a   week-to-week   or
month-to-month basis under a full service rental agreement,  which in most cases
includes a purchase option.  The customer may cancel the rental agreement at any
time without further obligation by returning the product to the  rental-purchase
operator.

     APRO, the industry's trade  association,  estimated that at the end of 1999
the U.S. rental-purchase industry comprised approximately 8,000 stores providing
7.5 million products to 3.3 million  households in the United States. We believe
that our customers  generally have annual household incomes ranging from $20,000
to $40,000.  Based on APRO  estimates,  the  rental-purchase  industry had gross
revenues of $4.7 billion in 1999.  The U.S.  rental-purchase  industry is highly
fragmented,  but is experiencing increased  consolidation.  Based on information
from APRO and  management  estimates,  the five  largest  industry  participants
account  for  approximately  52% of total  industry  stores,  with  the  largest
industry participant, Rent-A-Center, accounting for approximately 30.0% of those
stores, and management  estimates that the remainder of the industry consists of
operations with fewer than 20 stores.

                                       10
<PAGE>

     We believe that the  rental-purchase  industry is  experiencing  increasing
consolidation due to, among other factors,  the recognition by smaller operators
of  the  increased  operating   efficiencies  and  better  competitive  position
achievable by combining with larger operators,  greater  availability of capital
for larger operators,  and the willingness of older operators to sell as a means
of  resolving  business  succession  issues.  We believe  that this trend toward
consolidation  of  operations  in  the  industry  presents  an  opportunity  for
well-capitalized  rental-purchase  operators  to continue to acquire  additional
stores on favorable terms.

Strategy

     We believe that our continued success depends on successful  implementation
of the following business strategies:

Acquiring and Opening New Stores

     We currently  intend to expand our operations by acquiring  existing stores
and opening new stores,  both within our present  market area and in  geographic
regions we do not currently serve. At present, the majority of that expansion is
expected to be accomplished through  acquisitions.  We believe that acquisitions
can  effectively  increase our market share while  simultaneously  expanding our
customer  base.  In addition,  in pursuing our growth  strategies,  we expect to
benefit  from  both  enhanced  purchasing  power  and the  ability  to  leverage
economies of scale for several operating expenses.

     We  continually  review  acquisition  opportunities,  and we believe that a
number of acquisition  opportunities  currently  exist.  At present,  we have no
plans,  proposals,  arrangements or  understandings  with respect to significant
acquisitions.  In  identifying  targets for  acquisition,  we intend to focus on
operations  that  complement our existing  markets,  while remaining open to the
possibility  of making  acquisitions  in other  areas.  We have not  established
formal  criteria for  potential  acquisitions.  Generally,  however,  we seek to
acquire  rental-purchase  businesses that operate  profitably and are located in
geographic markets that complement our existing stores or that we view as growth
markets for the  rental-purchase  industry.  We seek to acquire these businesses
at purchase  prices that will permit us a prompt return on our investment in the
form  of  increased  earnings.   We  have  no  formal  policy  with  respect  to
acquisitions  with related  entities.  To date, none of these  acquisitions have
been considered nor do we anticipate  considering  any of these  acquisitions in
the future.  We believe  that our senior  management's  ability  and  experience
provides us with a competitive  advantage in the evaluation and  consummation of
acquisition opportunities.

     Following  consummation of an  acquisition,  we appoint a dedicated team to
oversee  and  monitor  the  integration  of  the  acquired   stores,   including
determining  staffing,   store  merchandise  and  facility  needs,  budgets  and
performance goals. All acquired stores are promptly evaluated and, if necessary,
remodeled.  We seek to integrate acquired stores and the management  information
system of those stores within one to three months following an acquisition.

                                       11
<PAGE>

     In addition, in May 1999, we announced a new store opening plan designed to
complement our acquisition  strategy. We plan to open an additional 40-60 stores
in the next twelve months.  The new store openings will occur in  under-serviced
markets  near  existing  locations  to leverage  field  operating  strength  and
advertising efficiencies.

Customer-Focused Philosophy

     We believe that through the continued adherence to our "Welcome, Wanted and
Important"  business philosophy we should be able to increase our new and repeat
customer base, and thus the number of units we have on rent,  thereby increasing
revenues and net income.  The "Welcome,  Wanted and  Important"  philosophy is a
method  by which we seek to  create a store  atmosphere  conducive  to  customer
loyalty.  We attempt to create  this  atmosphere  through the  effective  use of
advertising  and  merchandising   strategies,   by  maintaining  the  clean  and
well-stocked appearance of our stores, and by providing a high level of customer
service,  including the  institution  of a  1-800-RENTWAY  complaint and comment
line.  Our  advertising   emphasizes   brand  name   merchandise   from  leading
manufacturers.  In addition,  merchandise selection within each product category
is  periodically  updated to incorporate  the latest  offerings from  suppliers.
Services  provided by us to our customer include home delivery and installation,
ordinary  maintenance  and  repair  services  and pick up during the term of the
contract at no  additional  charge.  Store  managers also work closely with each
customer  in  choosing  merchandise,  setting  delivery  dates and  arranging  a
suitable  payment  schedule.  As part of the  "Welcome,  Wanted  and  Important"
philosophy,  store  managers  are  empowered,  encouraged  and  trained  to make
decisions regarding store operations subject only to our company-wide  operating
guidelines and general policies.

Expanding Our Product Lines

     One of our principal strategies is to provide the rental-purchase  customer
with  the  opportunity  to  obtain   merchandise  of  higher  quality  than  the
merchandise available from our competitors on competitive terms. To this end, we
attempt to maintain a broad  selection  of  products  while  emphasizing  better
quality,  higher  priced  merchandise.  We  intend  to  continue  expanding  our
offerings of better  quality,  higher priced  products in all product areas.  We
believe  that  previous  offerings  of these  products  have  succeeded  in both
increasing  our  profitability  and  attracting  new  customers  to our existing
stores.  In addition,  we selectively  test new  merchandise  and services.  Our
current  agreement to purchase Gateway  computers and offer them to customers in
part of our strategy of expanding  our product  line to include  higher  quality
products.  In addition,  our acquisition of an interest in dPi TeleConnect,  LLC
now enables us to offer prepaid local phone service to our customers in addition
to the traditional rental-purchase items. We believe that opportunities exist to
provide additional or non-traditional merchandise to our customers.

Monitoring Store Performance

     Our management information system allows each store manager to track rental
and collection  activity on a daily basis. The system generates detailed reports
that track inventory  movement  within each product  category and the number and
frequency  of  past  due  accounts  and  other  collection  activity.   Physical
inventories are regularly  conducted at each store to ensure the accuracy of the
management  information system data. Senior management monitors this information
to ensure adherence to established operating guidelines. In addition, each store
is provided with a monthly  profit and loss statement to track  performance.  We
believe our management and accounting information systems enhance our ability to
monitor and affect the operating performance of existing stores and to integrate
and improve the performance of newly acquired stores.

                                       12
<PAGE>

Results-Oriented Compensation

     We believe that an important reason for our positive financial  performance
and growth has been the  structure  of our  management  compensation  system.  A
significant  portion of our regional and store managers'  total  compensation is
dependent upon store performance. Regional and store managers earn incentives by
increasing both store revenues and operating profits.  As further incentive,  we
grant  managers  stock  options in  Rent-Way.  We believe  that our  emphasis on
incentive-based  compensation  has been  instrumental in our ability to attract,
retain and motivate our regional and store managers.

Manager Training and Empowerment

     We employ four  full-time  trainers who conduct  classroom  programs in the
areas of sales,  store  operations  and  personnel  management.  These  training
programs  often  continue for several  months and  culminate in an exam. We also
require our  managers  to attend,  at our  expense,  leadership  and  management
programs offered by leading management and organization  experts. We empower our
store managers by permitting them to make significant  decisions involving store
operations,  including personnel,  merchandise,  and collections  decisions.  We
believe that  well-trained  and  empowered  store  managers are important to our
efforts to maximize individual store performance.

Operations Our Stores

     We currently operate 1,094 stores in 42 states, as follows:

                    Location                 Number of Stores
                    --------                 ----------------
                    Texas                           120
                    Florida                         94
                    New York                        76
                    Pennsylvania                    64
                    Ohio                            61
                    South Carolina                  61
                    North Carolina                  45
                    Tennessee                       44
                    Indiana                         42
                    Georgia                         40
                    Louisiana                       39
                    Illinois                        39
                    Kentucky                        36
                    Arkansas                        34
                    Virginia                        32
                    Alabama                         29
                    Michigan                        28
                    Oklahoma                        16
                    Arizona                         16
                    Maryland                        15

                                       13
<PAGE>

                   Location                 Number of Stores
                    --------                 ----------------
                    Massachusetts                   14
                    Maine                           14
                    Missouri                        14
                    Mississippi                     12
                    Nebraska                        12
                    Kansas                          11
                    Colorado                        10
                    New Mexico                      10
                    New Hampshire                    9
                    Iowa                             8
                    West Virginia                    8
                    Vermont                          7
                    Nevada                           6
                    Connecticut                      5
                    Delaware                         5
                    Washington                       5
                    California                       4
                    Utah                             3
                    Rhode Island                     2
                    South Dakota                     2
                    Idaho                            1
                    Oregon                           1

     Our stores  average  3,500  square  feet in floor  space and are  generally
located in strip shopping centers in or near low to middle income neighborhoods.
Often,  these shopping  centers offer  convenient free parking to our customers.
Our stores are generally  uniform in interior  appearance and design and display
of available  merchandise.  The stores have separate storage areas but generally
do not use warehouse facilities.  In selecting store locations, we use a variety
of market information sources to locate areas of a town or city that are readily
accessible  to low and middle  income  consumers.  We believe  that within these
areas,  the best locations are in neighborhood  shopping  centers that include a
supermarket.  We believe this type of location makes frequent rental payments at
our stores more convenient for our customers. Generally, we refurbish our stores
every two to five years.

Product Selection

     We offer brand name home entertainment equipment,  such as television sets,
video  recorders,  video  cameras  and  stereos,  furniture,  major  appliances,
electronics and jewelry.  Major appliances offered by us include  refrigerators,
ranges, washers and dryers. Our product line currently includes the Zenith, RCA,
Pioneer,  JVC, Sharp and Panasonic brands in home entertainment  equipment,  the
Ashley and New England Corsair brand in furniture,  and the Crosley, Kenmore and
General Electric brands in major appliances.  In addition,  we now offer Gateway
personal  computers.  We closely monitor customer rental requests and adjust our
product mix to offer rental merchandise desired by customers.

                                       14
<PAGE>

     For the year ended  September  30,  1999,  payments  under  rental-purchase
contracts  for home  entertainment  products  accounted for  approximately  40%,
furniture 28.3%, appliances 26.5%, jewelry 3.9%, and all other items 0.6% of our
rental revenues.  Customers may rent either new merchandise or previously rented
merchandise.  Weekly  rentals  currently  range  from  $14.99 to $39.99 for home
entertainment  equipment,  from  $9.99 to $39.99  for  furniture,  from $9.99 to
$29.99 for major appliances and $6.99 to $19.99 for jewelry.

Rental-Purchase Agreements

     Merchandise  is  provided  to  customers   under  written   rental-purchase
agreements  that set forth the terms and conditions of the  transaction.  We use
standard form rental-purchase agreements which are reviewed by legal counsel and
customized to meet the legal  requirements  of the various  states in which they
are to be used. Generally, the rental-purchase agreement is signed at the store,
but may be signed at the customer's residence if the customer orders the product
by  telephone  and requests  home  delivery.  Customers  rent  merchandise  on a
week-to-week  and,  to a lesser  extent,  on a  month-to-month  basis  with rent
payable in advance. At the end of the initial and each subsequent rental period,
the customer  retains the  merchandise for an additional week or month by paying
the required rent or may terminate the agreement without further obligation.  If
the customer decides to terminate the agreement,  the merchandise is returned to
the store and is then available for rent to another customer. We retain title to
the merchandise during the term of the rental-purchase  agreement. If a customer
rents  merchandise  for a  sufficient  period of time,  usually 12 to 24 months,
ownership  is  transferred  to  the  customer  without  further  payments  being
required. Rental payments are typically made in cash or by check or money order.
We do not extend credit.

Product Turnover

     Generally, a minimum rental term of between 12 and 24 months is required to
obtain ownership of new merchandise. Based upon merchandise returns for the year
ended  September  30, 1999,  we believe  that the average  period of time during
which  customers rent  merchandise is 16 to 17 weeks.  However,  turnover varies
significantly  based on the type of merchandise being rented, with some consumer
electronic  products,  such as camcorders and VCRs,  generally  being rented for
shorter periods,  while appliances and furniture are generally rented for longer
periods.  Each  rental-purchase  transaction requires delivery and pickup of the
product,  weekly or monthly payment  processing  and, in some cases,  repair and
refurbishment  of the product.  In order to cover the relatively  high operating
expenses  generated  by greater  product  turnover,  rental-purchase  agreements
require larger aggregate  payments than are generally  charged under installment
purchase or credit plans.

Customer Service

     We offer same day delivery,  installation and pick-up of our merchandise at
no  additional  cost to the  customer.  We also provide any required  service or
repair without  charge,  except for damage in excess of normal wear and tear. If
the  product  cannot be  repaired  at the  customer's  residence,  we  provide a
temporary replacement while the product is being repaired. The customer is fully
liable for damage,  loss or destruction of the merchandise,  unless the customer
purchases an optional loss/damage waiver. Most of the products that we offer are
covered by a manufacturer's  warranty for varying periods, which, subject to the
terms of the  warranty,  is  transferred  to the  customer in the event that the
customer  obtains  ownership.  Repair  services  are provided  through  in-house
service  technicians,  independent  contractors or under factory warranties.  We
offer Rent-Way Plus, a fee-based  membership  program that provides special loss
and damage protection and an additional one year of service protection on rental
merchandise,   preferred  treatment  in  the  event  of  involuntary  job  loss,
accidental death and dismemberment  insurance and discounted  emergency roadside
assistance, as well as other discounts on merchandise and services.

                                       15
<PAGE>

Collections

     We believe  that  effective  collection  procedures  are  important  to our
success. Our collection procedures increase the revenue per product with minimal
associated  cost,  decrease the  likelihood  of default and reduce  charge-offs.
Senior  management,  as well as store managers use our  computerized  management
information  system to monitor cash collections on a daily basis. In the event a
customer fails to make a rental payment when due, store  management will attempt
to contact the  customer to obtain  payment and  reinstate  the contract or will
terminate  the  account  and arrange to regain  possession  of the  merchandise.
However,  store  managers  are  given  latitude  to  determine  the  appropriate
collection action to be pursued based on individual circumstances.  Depending on
state  regulatory  requirements,  we charge for the  reinstatement of terminated
accounts or collect a  delinquent  account  fee.  These fees are standard in the
industry and may be subject to state law  limitations.  Despite the fact that we
are not subject to the federal  Fair Debt  Collection  Practices  Act, it is our
policy to abide by the restrictions of this law in our collection procedures. If
an item on rent is not returned or payment is not received within 90 days of its
due  date,  our  policy is to charge  off the item.  Charge-offs  due to lost or
stolen  merchandise were  approximately  2.9%, 3.1% and 3.4% of our revenues for
the years ended September 30, 1999, 1998 and 1997, respectively.  The charge-off
rate for chains with over 40 stores reporting to APRO in 1998 was 3.3%.

Management

     Our stores are organized  geographically with several levels of management.
At the individual  store level,  each store manager is responsible  for customer
relations,  deliveries and pickups,  inventory management,  staffing and certain
marketing  efforts.  One of our stores normally  employs one store manager,  one
assistant  manager,  two account managers,  one full-time office manager and one
full-time delivery and installation technician.  The staffing of a store depends
on the number of rental-purchase contracts serviced by the store.

     Each store manager reports to one regional manager,  each of whom typically
oversees six to eight stores.  Regional  managers are primarily  responsible for
monitoring  individual  store  performance  and  inventory  levels  within their
respective  regions.  Our  regional  managers,  in turn,  report to directors of
operations,  who monitor the operations of their respective regions and, through
the regional managers, individual store performance. The directors of operations
report  to one of five  Divisional  Vice  Presidents  who  monitor  the  overall
operations of their assigned  geographic  area. The Divisional  Vice  Presidents
report  to  the  Vice   President-Operations  who  is  responsible  for  overall
Company-wide store operations. Senior management at our headquarters directs and
coordinates purchasing,  financial planning and controls, management information
systems,  employee  training,  personnel matters and acquisitions.  Headquarters
personnel also evaluate the performance of each store.

Management Information System

     We believe that our propriety  management  information  system  provides us
with a competitive advantage over many small rental-purchase  operations. We use
an integrated  computerized  management  information and control system to track
each unit of merchandise  and each  rental-purchase  agreement.  Our system also
includes  extensive  management  software  and report  generating  capabilities.
Reports  for  all  stores  are  reviewed  daily  by  senior  management  and any
irregularities  are  addressed  the  following  business day. Each store has the
ability to track individual  components of revenue,  idle items,  items on rent,
delinquent  accounts and other account  information.  Management  electronically
gathers  each  day's  activity  report  through  the  computer  located  at  the
headquarters  office.  Our  management  has access to  operating  and  financial
information about any store location or region in which we operate and generates
management  reports on a daily,  weekly,  month-to-date and year-to-date  basis.
Utilizing  the  management  information  system,  senior  management,   regional
managers and store managers can closely monitor the productivity of stores under
their supervision  compared to  Company-prescribed  guidelines.  This system has
enabled us to expand our operations  while  maintaining a high degree of control
over cash receipts,  rental merchandise,  and merchandise units in repair. While
we believe our management  information  system is adequate to meet our needs for
the foreseeable future, we continue to upgrade the system over time.

                                       16
<PAGE>

Purchasing and Distribution

     Our general  product mix is  determined by senior  management,  based on an
analysis of customer rental patterns and  introduction of new products on a test
basis.  Individual store managers are responsible for determining the particular
product  selection  for their store from a list of  products  approved by senior
management.  All purchase orders are executed through regional  managers and our
purchasing  department to ensure that  inventory  levels and mix  throughout the
store  regions  are  appropriate.  We purchase  our  merchandise  directly  from
manufacturers or  distributors.  With the exception of our recent agreement with
Gateway for personal computers, we generally do not enter into written contracts
with our  suppliers.  Although  we  currently  expect to continue  our  existing
relationships,  we believe there are numerous  sources of products  available to
us, and do not believe  that the success of our  operations  is dependent on any
one or more of our present suppliers.

Marketing and Advertising

     We promote our products and services through targeted direct mail, spot and
national  television  advertising  and, to a lesser  extent,  through  radio and
secondary  print media  advertisement.  We also solicit  business by telephoning
former and prospective customers.  We are dedicating an increasing percentage of
our marketing  dollars to television  advertising to build brand  recognition in
markets where it is economically  attractive to do so. Our print  advertisements
emphasize product and brand name selection,  prompt delivery and repair, and the
absence of any down  payment,  credit  investigation  or  long-term  obligation.
Advertising expense as a percentage of revenue for the years ended September 30,
1999, 1998 and 1997 were 4.7%, 5.4% and 5.6%,  respectively.  In addition to our
national  advertising  efforts,  a good deal of emphasis  has been placed on the
development  of a local  store  marketing  plan to allow the stores to  leverage
market specific knowledge.  As we obtain new stores in our existing markets, the
advertising  expenses  of each store in the market can be reduced by listing all
stores in the same  market-wide  advertisement.  In addition,  we participate in
cooperative advertising programs with many of our major vendors.

Competition

     The rental-purchase  industry is highly competitive.  We compete with other
rental-purchase  businesses  as well as rental  stores  that do not offer  their
customers a purchase option.  Competition is based primarily on rental rates and
terms, product selection and availability, and customer service. With respect to
consumers  who are able to  purchase a product  for cash or on  credit,  we also
compete with department stores, discount stores and retail outlets that offer an
installment  sales program or offer comparable  products and prices.  We are the
second  largest  operator  in  the  rental-purchase  industry,  second  only  to
Rent-A-Center.  Rent-A-Center is national in scope and has significantly greater
financial and operating resources and name recognition than we have.

                                       17
<PAGE>

Properties

     We generally lease all of our store  facilities under operating leases that
generally  have terms of three to five years and require that we pay real estate
taxes, utilities and maintenance. We have optional renewal privileges on most of
our leases for  additional  periods  ranging  from three to five years at rental
rates  generally  adjusted  for  increases  in the cost of  living.  There is no
assurance that we can renew the leases that do not contain renewal  options,  or
that if we can renew them,  that the terms will be  favorable  to us. We believe
that suitable store space is generally  available for lease and that we would be
able to relocate any of our stores without  significant  difficulty should we be
unable to renew a particular lease. We also expect that additional space will be
readily  available  at  competitive  rates in the  event we  desire  to open new
stores.

     Our main corporate  offices are in Erie,  Pennsylvania and consist of three
buildings of  approximately  34,000,  11,000,  and 10,000  square  feet.  During
calendar  year 2000,  we plan to construct a 30,000  square foot addition to our
main  corporate  headquarters.   We  estimate  the  cost  of  this  addition  at
approximately  $3.5 million and plan to pay for this project with  borrowings on
our senior credit  facility.  In addition,  we lease  administrative  offices in
Dallas,  Texas,  Daytona,  Florida,  Lexington,  Kentucky,  and  Raleigh,  North
Carolina.  We also own two office buildings in Erie,  Pennsylvania that are used
for record storage.

Personnel

     As of April 1, 2000, we had approximately 5,500 employees,  of whom 250 are
located at the corporate office in Erie, Pennsylvania.  None of our employees is
represented  by a labor union.  We believe our relations  with our employees are
good.

Government Regulation

     Forty-seven  states  have  adopted  legislation   regulating  or  otherwise
impacting the rental-purchase transaction.  These laws generally require certain
contractual and advertising disclosures concerning the nature of the transaction
and also provide  varying levels of  substantive  consumer  protection,  such as
requiring a grace period for late payments and contract  reinstatement rights in
the event the agreement is terminated for nonpayment.

     Recent court decisions in Minnesota, New Jersey, and Wisconsin have created
a legal  environment  in those states which is  prohibitive  to  rental-purchase
transactions.  We do not operate in those states.  The majority of the states in
which  we  operate  impose  some  type of  disclosure  requirements,  either  in
advertising or in the  rental-purchase  agreement,  or both. The  regulations in
these states also distinguish rental-purchase transactions from credit sales. We
believe that our operations are in material  compliance  with  applicable  state
rental-purchase laws.

     No federal  legislation  has been enacted  regulating  the  rental-purchase
transaction.  We instruct our managers in procedures  required by applicable law
through  training  seminars and policy manuals and believe that we have operated
in compliance with the requirements of applicable law in all material respects.

     We  believe  that in the  unlikely  event  federal  legislation  is enacted
regulating  rental-purchase  transactions  as credit sales,  we would be able to
adapt to the new laws and remain  profitable  by  repositioning  ourselves  as a
rent-to-rent business.

                                       18
<PAGE>

Service Marks

     We have  registered  the  "Rent-Way"  service mark under the Lanham Act. We
believe that this mark has acquired  significant market recognition and goodwill
in the communities in which our stores are located.  We have also registered the
service marks "Rent-Way  Because There's Really Only One Way" and "RentWay - the
Right  Way" and the  related  designs.  We have also  prepared  applications  to
register the following  service  marks:  "RentWay.  The Right Way. Right Away.",
"Lifetime  Reinstatement",  and  "We're  Changing  the Way  America  Rents".  In
connection  with the Home Choice merger,  we acquired the "Home Choice"  service
mark, which is registered under the Lanham Act.

Legal Proceedings

     From time to time we are a party to various  legal  proceedings  arising in
the  ordinary  course  of our  business.  We are not  currently  a party  to any
material litigation.

                                       19
<PAGE>

                                 USE OF PROCEEDS

     We will not receive any proceeds  from sale of the common stock  offered by
the selling shareholders.

                              SELLING SHAREHOLDERS

     The following table sets forth the number of shares of common stock offered
by the selling shareholders in this prospectus based upon information  furnished
to us:

<TABLE>
<CAPTION>

                             Number of Shares     Number of Shares       Number of Shares    Percentage of
                             of Common Stock      of Common Stock        of Common Stock     Outstanding Common
                             Owned Prior to       Offered for Sale       Owned After the     Stock Owned After
Name                         the Offering         in the Offering        Offering            the Offering
----                         ----------------     ----------------       ---------------     ------------------
<S>                             <C>                   <C>                      <C>                  <C>
Larry Kugler                    23,072                23,072                   --                   --

Thomas H. Lowe                  23,185                23,185                   --                   --

Jeri F. Slatton                 23,185                23,185                   --                   --

Mollie Dockery Tackett          23,185                23,185                   --                   --

Gregory T. J. Madson            23,185                23,185                   --                   --

</TABLE>

     The  shares of common  stock  being  offered  in this  prospectus  underlie
options  granted in July 1995 to the former  shareholders  of  McKenzie  Leasing
Corporation in connection with our acquisition of McKenzie Leasing  Corporation.
The options were subsequently sold to the selling shareholders on or about April
12,  2000.  Except  as  described  in  this  prospectus,  none  of  the  selling
shareholders  has had any  position,  office or  material  relationship  with us
within the past three years.

                                       20
<PAGE>

                              PLAN OF DISTRIBUTION

     The common stock offered by this prospectus is being offered by the selling
shareholders.  Such common stock may be sold or distributed from time to time by
the selling shareholders, or by donees or transferees of, or other successors in
interests to, the selling  shareholders,  directly to one or more  purchasers or
through  brokers,  dealers or  underwriters  who may act solely as agents or may
acquire such common stock as principals, at market prices prevailing at the time
of sale,  at prices  related to such  prevailing  market  prices,  at negotiated
prices, or at fixed prices,  which may be changed.  The sale of the common stock
offered hereby may be effected in one or more of the following methods:

     -    ordinary brokers' transactions;
     -    purchases by brokers,  dealers or  underwriters  as principal who then
          resell for their own accounts pursuant to this prospectus;
     -    "at the market" to or through market makers or into an existing market
          for the common stock;
     -    in other  ways not  involving  market  makers or  established  trading
          markets,  including  direct  sales to  purchasers  or  sales  effected
          through agents;
     -    in privately negotiated transactions;
     -    through a pledge to a lending institution; or
     -    any combination of the foregoing.

     In  order  to  comply  with  the  securities  laws of  certain  states,  if
applicable,  the shares may be sold only through  registered or licensed brokers
or dealers.  In addition,  in certain states,  the shares may not be sold unless
they have been  registered  or qualified  for sale in such state or an exemption
from such  registration or  qualification  requirement is available and complied
with.

     Brokers, dealers,  underwriters or agents participating in the distribution
of the shares as agents may  receive  compensation  in the form of  commissions,
discounts or concessions from the selling  shareholders and/or purchasers of the
common stock for whom such  broker-dealers may act as agent, or to whom they may
sell as principal, or both (which compensation as to a particular  broker-dealer
may be less than or in excess of customary commissions).

     THE SELLING  SHAREHOLDERS AND ANY BROKER-DEALERS WHO ACT IN CONNECTION WITH
THE SALE OF THE SHARES HEREUNDER MAY BE DEEMED TO BE  "UNDERWRITERS"  WITHIN THE
MEANING OF THE SECURITIES ACT, AND ANY COMMISSIONS  THEY RECEIVE AND PROCEEDS OF
ANY  SALE  OF  THE  SHARES  MAY  BE  DEEMED  TO BE  UNDERWRITING  DISCOUNTS  AND
COMMISSIONS UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT.

     Neither Rent-Way nor the selling  shareholders  can presently  estimate the
amount of such compensation.  Rent-Way knows of no existing arrangements between
any selling shareholders, any other shareholder,  broker, dealer, underwriter or
agent relating to the sale or distribution of the shares. At a time a particular
offer  of  shares  is  made,  a  prospectus  supplement,  if  required  will  be
distributed that will set forth the names of any agents, underwriters or dealers
and any  compensation  from the  selling  shareholders  and any  other  required
information.

     Rent-Way  will  pay  all  of the  expenses  incident  to the  registration,
offering and sale of shares to the public other than commissions or discounts of
underwriters,  broker-dealers  or agents.  Rent-Way has also agreed to indemnify
the  selling   shareholders   and  certain   related   persons  against  certain
liabilities, including liabilities under the Securities Act.

                                       21
<PAGE>

     Insofar as indemnification for liabilities arising under the Securities Act
may be permitted to  directors,  officers and  controlling  persons of Rent-Way,
Rent-Way has been advised that in the opinion of the SEC such indemnification is
against  public  policy as expressed  in the  Securities  Act and is  therefore,
unenforceable.

     Rent-Way has advised the selling shareholders that during such time as they
may be engaged in a distribution  of the shares included in this prospectus they
are  required to comply  with  Regulation  M  promulgated  under the  Securities
Exchange  Act of  1934,  as  amended.  With  certain  exceptions,  Regulation  M
precludes  the  selling  shareholders,   any  affiliated  purchasers,   and  any
broker-dealer or other person who participates in such distribution from bidding
for or purchasing, or attempting to induce any person to bid for or purchase any
security which is the subject of the distribution until the entire  distribution
is complete.  Regulation M also prohibits any bids or purchases made in order to
stabilize the price of a security in connection  with the  distribution  of that
security.  All of the  foregoing  may  affect  the  marketability  of the shares
offered hereby.

                                  LEGAL MATTERS

     The validity of the common stock offered in this  prospectus will be passed
upon for us by Hodgson, Russ, Andrews, Woods & Goodyear LLP, Buffalo, New York.

                                     EXPERTS

     Our  balance  sheets  as of  September  30,  1999 and 1998 and the  related
statements  of income,  shareholders'  equity and cash flows for the years ended
September  30, 1999,  1998 and 1997,  all  incorporated  by reference  into this
registration  statement  and  prospectus,   have  been  incorporated  into  this
registration   statement   and   prospectus   in  reliance  on  the  reports  of
PricewaterhouseCoopers  LLP, independent accountants,  given on the authority of
that firm as experts in accounting and auditing.

                                       22
<PAGE>

                              ABOUT THIS PROSPECTUS

     This prospectus may be used by the selling  shareholders  identified  under
the heading  "SELLING  SHAREHOLDERS"  in connection with their sale of shares of
common stock which they own or acquire from us by the exercise of stock options.
The selling shareholders may also sell their shares of common stock by complying
with Rule 144 or Rule 144A adopted by the  Securities  and  Exchange  Commission
under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, if the requirements of those rules
have been satisfied.

     The selling  shareholders will receive all of the proceeds from their sales
of the common stock. We will not receive any money from these sales.

     This  prospectus  provides you with a general  description of us and of our
common  stock.  You should  carefully  read this  prospectus  and the  documents
referred  to in this  prospectus  under  the  heading  "WHERE  YOU CAN FIND MORE
INFORMATION."  You  should  rely  only  on  the  information  provided  in  this
prospectus  or  incorporated  into this  prospectus  by  reference.  We have not
authorized  anyone to provide  you with  different  information.  You should not
assume that the  information  in this  prospectus is accurate  after the date of
this prospectus.

                       WHERE YOU CAN FIND MORE INFORMATION

     We have filed a  registration  statement  with the SEC relating to sales by
the selling  shareholders  of their shares of common stock.  This  prospectus is
part  of  that  registration  statement,  but the  registration  statement  also
contains  additional  information and exhibits.  We also file proxy  statements,
annual,  quarterly and special reports and other  information  with the SEC. You
may read and copy  (upon the  payment of fees  charges by the SEC) any  document
that we file with the SEC at its public  reference rooms in Washington,  DC (450
Fifth Street,  N.W.,  Washington,  DC 20549),  New York, New York (7 World Trade
Center,  Suite 300,  New York,  New York  10048),  and Chicago (500 West Madison
Street,  Suite 1400,  Chicago,  Illinois 60661). You may call the SEC at 1-(800)
SEC-0330 for further  information  about the public reference rooms. Our filings
are also available at the SEC's website at Our Internet address is

     The SEC allows us to incorporate documents in this prospectus by reference.
This  means  that  we can  disclose  important  business,  financial  and  other
information in our SEC filings by referring you to the documents containing such
information.   All  information  incorporated  by  reference  is  part  of  this
prospectus  until it is updated by future  filings  with the SEC.  Those  future
filings are considered to automatically update this prospectus.

     We incorporate by reference  into this  prospectus the documents  listed in
the following table:

     Our SEC Filings                            Period
     ---------------                            ------
Annual  Report on Form 10-K             Year ended  September 30, 1999
Quarterly  Report on Form 10-Q          Quarter ended December 31, 1999
Quarterly  Report on Form 10-Q          Quarter ended March 31, 2000
Current  Reports on Form 8-K            Dated:  January 19, 2000 (two reports)
                                                February 15, 2000
                                                February 29, 2000
                                                April 11, 2000
                                                April 25, 2000

Registration  Statement on Form 8-A     Filed September 30, 1998, including any
containing a description of our         amendments or reports filed for the
common stock                            purpose of updating such description

                                       23
<PAGE>

     We also  incorporate  by reference  additional  documents  that we may file
between the date of this  prospectus and the termination of the offering made by
use of this prospectus.  These documents include periodic reports such as Annual
Reports on Forms 10-K,  Quarterly Reports on Forms 10-Q, Current Reports on Form
8-K, and other reports filed with the SEC, as well as proxy statements.

     You can obtain  any of the  documents  incorporated  by  reference  in this
prospectus from us, other than exhibits to those documents unless the exhibit is
specifically  incorporated by reference into this prospectus as an exhibit.  You
can obtain documents  incorporated by reference in this prospectus by requesting
them in writing or by telephone  from us at the following  address and telephone
number:

                               Investor Relations
                                 RENT-WAY, INC.
                                One RentWay Place
                            Erie, Pennsylvania 16505
                                 (814) 455-5378

To ensure  timely  receipt of documents  that you  request,  you should make any
request to us at least five  business  days prior to the date you need them.  We
will mail materials to you by first class mail, or another equally prompt means,
within one business day after we receive your request.

                                       24
<PAGE>

                                 RENT-WAY, INC.

                                 115,812 SHARES

                                       OF

                                  COMMON STOCK

                                  ------------
                                   PROSPECTUS

                                  ------------

                                  June 1, 2000



                                       25
<PAGE>

                                     PART II

                     INFORMATION NOT REQUIRED IN PROSPECTUS

Item 14.  Other Expenses of Issuance and Distribution

     The expenses to be incurred in  connection  with the offering are set forth
below. The selling  shareholders will not pay any expenses of the offering.  All
amounts are estimates except the SEC registration fee.

SEC registration fee .........................  $    779.00
Accounting fees and expenses .................     5,000.00
Legal fees and expenses ......................    10,000.00
Blue Sky Fees and Expenses ...................     2,000.00
Miscellaneous ................................     1,000.00

    Total ....................................   $18,779.00

Item 15.  Indemnification of Directors and Officers

     The provisions of Sections 1741 through 1750 of the  Pennsylvania  Business
Corporation Law provide that a corporation shall have the power to indemnify any
person who was or is a party or is  threatened  to be made a party to any action
or proceeding,  whether civil,  criminal,  administrative or  investigative,  by
reason of the fact that he or she is or was a representative of the corporation,
against expenses (including attorney's fees), judgments,  fines and amounts paid
in settlement actually and reasonably incurred by such person in connection with
the  action or  proceeding  if they  acted in good  faith  and in a manner  they
reasonably  believed  to be in, or not  opposed  to, the best  interests  of the
corporation.  To the extent that a  representative  of the  corporation has been
successful  on the merits or otherwise in defense of any action or proceeding or
in defense of any claim, issue or matter therein, the corporation is required by
the  Pennsylvania  Business  Corporation Law to indemnify them against  expenses
actually and reasonably incurred by them in connection with their defense.

     Rent-Way's  By-Laws  provide  that it  shall  indemnity  its  officers  and
directors  against claims arising from actions taken in their official  capacity
except  where the conduct  giving rise to the claim is finally  determined  by a
court or in arbitration to have constituted  willful  misconduct or recklessness
or to have involved the receipt from Rent-Way of a personal benefit to which the
officer or director  was not  entitled,  or where the  indemnification  has been
determined in a final  adjudication to be unlawful.  Rent-Way may create a fund,
trust or other arrangement to secure the indemnification.  In addition, Rent-Way
is  required  to pay the  expenses  of  defending  the claim in advance of final
adjudication  upon the receipt of an  undertaking  by the officer or director to
repay the advanced  amounts if it is ultimately  determined  that the officer or
director is not entitled to be indemnified.  These provisions of the By-Laws are
expressly permitted pursuant to the Pennsylvania Business Corporation Law.

                                      II-1
<PAGE>

Item 16.  Exhibits

Exhibit No.         Description
-----------         -----------
 5.1(1)             Opinion of Hodgson, Russ, Andrews, Woods & Goodyear, LLP

10.1(2)             Form of Stock Option Agreements between the Company and each
                    of the former shareholders of McKenzie Leasing Corporation,
                    dated July 21, 1995

10.2(1)             Form of Stock Option Assignment Agreement

23.1(1)             Consent of Hodgson, Russ, Andrews, Woods & Goodyear, LLP
                    (included in Exhibit 5.1)

23.2(1)             Consent of PricewaterhouseCoopers, LLP

------------------------------

(1)  Filed herewith.

(2)  Previously  filed,  as of January 5, 1996,  as an exhibit to the  Company's
     Registration Statement on Form SB-2.

                                      II-2

<PAGE>

Item 17.  Undertakings

     (a) Insofar as indemnification for liabilities arising under the Securities
Act may be permitted to directors,  officers and controlling persons of Rent-Way
pursuant to the foregoing  provisions  or  otherwise,  Rent-Way has been advised
that  in  the  opinion  of  the   Securities   and  Exchange   Commission   such
indemnification  is against public policy as expressed in the Securities Act and
is,  therefore,  unenforceable.  In the event  that a claim for  indemnification
against  these  liabilities,  other than the  payment by  Rent-Way  of  expenses
incurred or paid by a director, officer or controlling person of Rent-Way in the
successful defense of any action, suit or proceeding, is asserted by a director,
officer  or  controlling   person  in  connection  with  the  securities   being
registered,  Rent-Way will,  unless in the opinion of its counsel the matter has
been  settled  by  controlling  precedent,  submit  to a  court  of  appropriate
jurisdiction the question whether indemnification by it is against public policy
as  expressed  in  the  Securities  Act  and  will  be  governed  by  the  final
adjudication of the issue.

     (b) Rent-Way also hereby undertakes that:

          (1) To file,  during  any  period  in which  offers or sales are being
made, a post-effective amendment to this Registration Statement:

               (i) To include any prospectus required by Section 10(a)(3) of the
Securities Act;

               (ii) To reflect  in the  prospectus  any facts or events  arising
after the  effective  date of the  Registration  Statement,  or the most  recent
post-effective amendment of the Registration Statement,  which,  individually or
in the aggregate, represent a fundamental change in the information set forth in
the Registration Statement; and

               (iii) To include any  material  information  with  respect to the
plan of distribution not previously  disclosed in the Registration  Statement or
any material change to the information in the Registration Statement;

     Provided, however, that paragraphs (b)(1)(i) and (b)(1)(ii) do not apply if
the information  required to be included in a post-effective  amendment by those
paragraphs  is  contained  in periodic  reports  filed with or  furnished to the
Commission by Rent-Way  pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Exchange Act that
are incorporated by reference in the Registration Statement.

          (2) That for the  purposes  of  determining  any  liability  under the
Securities  Act,  each  such  post-effective   shall  be  deemed  to  be  a  new
registration  statement  relating to the securities offered in that registration
statement,  and the offering of those securities at that time shall be deemed to
be the initial bona fide offer to sell those securities.

          (3) To remove from registration by means of a post-effective amendment
any of the securities being registered which remain unsold at the termination of
the offering.

     (c)  Rent-Way  hereby  undertakes  that,  for purposes of  determining  any
liability  under the  Securities  Act, each filing of  Rent-Way's  annual report
pursuant to Section  13(a) or Section  15(d) of the  Exchange  Act,  and,  where
applicable,  each filing of an employee benefit plan's annual report pursuant to
Section 15(d) of Rent-Way Exchange Act, that is incorporated by reference in the
Registration  Statement  shall  be  deemed  to be a new  registration  statement
relating  to the  securities  offered in that  registration  statement,  and the
offering of those securities at that time shall be deemed to be the initial bona
fide offering of those securities.

                                      II-3

<PAGE>

                                   SIGNATURES

     Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Act, Rent-Way certifies that
it has reasonable  grounds to believe that it meets all of the  requirements  of
filing on Form S-3 and has duly caused this Registration  Statement to be signed
on its behalf by the  undersigned  who are duly  authorized in the City of Erie,
State of Pennsylvania, on June 1, 2000.

                             RENT-WAY, INC.


                             By:  /s/ William E. Morgenstern
                                  -----------------------------------
                                  William E. Morgenstern, Chairman of the Board,
                                  Chief Executive Officer

     In  accordance   with  the   requirements   of  the  Securities  Act,  this
Registration Statement was signed by the following persons in the capacities and
on the date stated.

<TABLE>
<CAPTION>

        Signature                                 Title                                  Date
        ---------                                 -----                                  ----
<S>                                        <C>                                        <C>
/s/ William E. Morgenstern                 Chairman of the Board and Chief            June 1, 2000
----------------------------------         Executive Officer and Director
William E. Morgenstern                     (Principal Executive Officer)


/s/ William A. McDonnell                   Vice President, Chief Financial Officer    June 1, 2000
----------------------------------         (Principal Financial Officer)
William A. McDonnell


/s/ Jeffrey A. Conway                      President, Chief Operating Officer and     June 1, 2000
--------------------------------------     Director
Jeffrey A. Conway


/s/ Gerald A. Ryan                         Chairman Emeritus, Director                June 1, 2000
-----------------------------------------
Gerald A. Ryan


/s/ Vincent A. Carrino                     Director                                   June 1, 2000
-----------------------------------------
Vincent A. Carrino


/s/ Robert B. Fagenson                     Director                                   June 1, 2000
-----------------------------------------
Robert B. Fagenson


/s/ Marc W. Joseffer                       Director                                   June 1, 2000
-----------------------------------------
Marc W. Joseffer


/s/ William Lerner                         Director                                   June 1, 2000
-----------------------------------------
William Lerner


/s/ Jacqueline Woods                       Director                                   June 1, 2000
-----------------------------------------
Jacqueline Woods
</TABLE>
                                      II-4
<PAGE>

         EXHIBIT INDEX

Exhibit No.         Description
-----------         -----------
5.1(1)              Opinion of Hodgson, Russ, Andrews, Woods & Goodyear, LLP

10.1(2)             Form of Stock Option Agreements between the Company and each
                    of the former shareholders of McKenzie Leasing Corporation,
                    dated July 21, 1995

10.2(1)             Form of Stock Option Assignment Agreement

23.1(1)             Consent of Hodgson, Russ, Andrews, Woods & Goodyear, LLP
                    (included in Exhibit 5.1)

23.2(1)             Consent of PricewaterhouseCoopers, LLP

------------------------------

(1)  Filed herewith.

(2)  Previously  filed,  as of January 5, 1996,  as an exhibit to the  Company's
     Registration Statement on Form SB-2.



© 2022 IncJournal is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission